The Sociopolitical Role of the Unconscious

Christopher Bollas, most of whose books I have read and benefited from, including those discussed elsewhere, speaks of "normotic illness," one of whose features is a denial of the existence of the unconscious mind. But in the world we are living in today, especially in these United States, can anyone for a moment deny the power of unconscious forces and traumas all around us, not least emanating from the current occupant of the White House?

 Bollas has an essay in a recent collection along with other scholars and clinicians: David Morgan, ed., The Unconscious in Social and Political Life (Phoenix Press, 2019), 318pp. 

 About this collection the publisher tells us this:
Traumatic events happen in every age, yet there is a particularly cataclysmic feeling to our own epoch that is so attractive to some and so terrifying to others. The terrible events of September 11th 2001 still resonate and the repercussions continue to this day: the desperation of immigrants fleeing terror, the uncertainty of Brexit, Donald Trump in the White House, the rise of the alt-right and hard left, increasing fundamentalism, and terror groups intent on causing destruction to the Western way of life. If that were not enough, we also have to grapple with the enormity of climate change and the charge that if we do not act now, it will be too late. Is it any wonder many are left overwhelmed by the events they see on the news?
Galvanised by the events outside of his consulting room, in 2015, David Morgan began The Political Mind seminars at the British Psychoanalytical Society and their successful run continues today. A series of superlative seminars, mostly presented by colleagues from the British Society plus a few select external experts, that examine a dazzling array of relevant topics to provide a psychoanalytic understanding of just what is going on in our world. This book is the first in The Political Mind series to bring these seminars to a wider audience.
The Unconscious in Political and Social Life contains compelling contributions from Christopher Bollas, Michael Rustin, Jonathan Sklar, David Bell, Philip Stokoe, Roger Kennedy, David Morgan, M. Fakhry Davids, Ruth McCall, R. D. Hinshelwood, Renée Danziger, Josh Cohen, Sally Weintrobe, and Margot Waddell. They investigate so many vital issues affecting us today: the evolution of democracy, right-wing populism, prejudice, the rise of the far right, attitudes to refugees and migrants, neoliberalism, fundamentalism, terrorism, the Palestine-Israel situation, political change, feminism, austerity in the UK, financial globalisation, and climate change.
This book needs to be read by all who are concerned by the state of the world today. Psychoanalysis and psychoanalysts with their awareness of what motivates human beings bring clarity and fresh insight to these matters. A deeper understanding of humanity awaits the reader of The Unconscious in Political and Social Life.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Amish Sexuality: An Interview with James Cates

I heard a great lecture in August by Dr James Cates on his pioneering clinical work with the Amish in northern Indiana, and I was instantly fascinated by his experience, and even more so by his two main books on the topic.  In 2014, Johns Hopkins University Press published his Serving the Amish . And then Serpent in the Garden: Amish Sexuality in a Changing World  was published just a few weeks ago (JHU Press, 2020), 224pp. I reached out to him by e-mail to interview him about the book, which I read on a lovely weekend in mid-September sitting outside in near-perfect weather. It is an elegantly written and deeply interesting study, making all sorts of unexpected connections, and I sent him some questions about it. Here are his thoughts: AD: Tell us about your background JC: That question almost always prompts me to say, “I’m a clinical psychologist,” and start with my history in the mental health field. That background contributes to this work, but my love of writing predates my intere
Read more

Making Contact: Leston Havens on the Uses of Language in Psychotherapy

People for whom I have very great respect, and from whom I have learned and continue to learn much, have said very laudatory things about Paul Wachtel's book Therapeutic Communication: Knowing What to Say When . I have read it twice, and recommended it to students and interns albeit diffidently because I was sure I must have missed a great deal in the book because of my general dimness, laziness, or both.  And yet, on both readings--three years apart--it has struck me as unnecessarily dense and prolix, needlessly complicated in places, and in want of more ruthless editing. The writing style is also entirely forgettable--it has little charm and even less humour. Does it have valuable things to say? Without doubt. Have I learned from it? Certainly. Does it fill a gap in the contemporary literature? Yes.  But does it allow itself with some facility to translate memorably into clinical practice? No, it does not, at least for me. Along comes a book treating the same issue but doing so i
Read more

Wilfred Bion on Memory and Desire

I've read rather a lot in British object relations theory, and of the psychoanalysts associated with the Middle/Independent "school" in the United Kingdom--those who refused in the main to get drawn into the "Controversial Discussions" resulting from the split between the Kleinians and the (Anna) Freudians in the early 1940s. But one figure of significance, who wrote a considerable number of dense books I have not yet read, remains on my list of those to explore: Wilfred Bion . (I've found the book by the Symingtons, The Clinical Thinking of Wilfred Bion , a very helpful place to start. There they emphasize the overriding lesson to therapists from Bion is:  Think and speak from your own heart and mind. ) I have, however, read a couple of Bion's essays on Memory and Desire , and seen one passage from them quoted in many places over the years: the therapist must approach each session with the same patient "without memory or desire." I admit I w
Read more