Posts

Showing posts with the label Carl Rogers

Miller and Moyers on Effective Psychotherapists

If you're like me, you've already somewhat obsessively read at least forty-seven articles on the working alliance and an array of related topics to discover what the best therapists do. One of the reasons I started this wee blog was to share such findings as I come across them.

Over the past few years a picture has built up. It is simultaneously reassuring and terrifying that much of psychotherapy turns not on technique nor years of practice (nor still less--thankfully--on the absurd array of trademarked acronyms promising to move the sun and the other stars), but on certain gifts and characteristics that the therapist either seems to have--or not. In this, it puts me in mind once again of Anna Freud's aphorism (recorded in Robert Coles' workable biography of her) that therapists are either technicians or healers. 

This brand new book does not put it quite so bluntly, but the authors do repeatedly note that the best healers in psychotherapy seem to have certain qualities in abundance and to exercise them rather freely. This book is eminently useful in putting before the reader the latest data on what makes for a masterful therapist: Effective Psychotherapists: Clinical Skills That Improve Client Outcomes by William R. Miller and Theresa B. Moyers (Guilford Press, 2021), 213pp. 

Miller, of course, is the author of the famous work Motivational Interviewing, which generations of clinicians have heard about if not actually read. (I have read it. It was ever so slightly underwhelming.) Here he teams up with Moyers to write several very workable chapters that eschew fulgurating fireworks and convey some basic qualities and characteristics with clarity. 

Right from the get-go the authors reveal the crucial finding: already by the end of the first session, much of the outcome of therapy can be predicted. How is that possible? On what is success predicated so swiftly?

The answer will not surprise you if you are familiar with contemporary research into effective psychotherapists, who have compassion, empathy, and the ability to build a partnership with their patients in what is called the working alliance. These qualities are not time-dependent, either: a novice intern can have them and use them as or even more effectively than someone in practice for thirty years. More on all this in a moment. 

This book, Effective Psychotherapists, is divided into three unequal sections. The first, the shortest, nonetheless lays out the centrality of effective empathy as key to the working alliance. The second part, the longest, focuses on what the authors call the eight therapeutic skills you can develop and improve so that patient outcomes also improve. The third and final section contains three chapters and broadly focuses on ongoing training and future developments.

Chapter II, in the first section, is they key to the entire book. Here the authors review more than half a century of research into therapist effects to show that "the answer...is startlingly clear" to the question: what distinguishes a great therapist from the rest? In one study, that answer was almost immediately manifest: a "higher expression of therapist empathy" was found to predict "greater reduction in alcohol use" (p.10) and this could already be noted "as early as the first session" (p.11). 

They go on to note that therapists vary in their abilities and successes both between each other and with different patients: "even the best therapists are not effective with every client" (p.13). As a result, it is important not to overlook "the fit between client characteristics and therapist skills" (p.14). Nina Coltart first alerted me to this in her writing on the importance of careful intake assessment to see whether there is a good fit, and, if not, to carefully consider whom one might refer a patient to for a better fit. 

Chapter III gets into empathy in detail, considered here as "accurate empathy." The authors introduce the qualifier "accurate" to reflect the fact that a good psychotherapist will modify his or her own affect in response to what the patient is manifesting in the moment. They will also draw on their own curiosity to find out more about what the patient is feeling and experiencing. 

Accuracy may also enjoin patience upon the patient and therapist alike. That is to say, psychotherapy may be seen as an invitation to slow down to engage in Listening with the Third Ear for the voices of (in Eliot's lovely words) 

the children in the apple-tree/Not known, because not looked for
But heard, half-heard, in the stillness/Between two waves of the sea.
Quick now, here, now, always—/A condition of complete simplicity
(Costing not less than everything)

Accurate empathy's power, the authors flatly note in this chapter, is well documented now. Drawing on the results of "a meta-analysis of 82 independent" studies, it is clear that "of all the therapeutic factors that have been studied, accurate empathy has the most consistent relationship to positive client outcomes" (p.29).

Chapters IV-VI strike a very Rogerian note. Chapter IV, on Acceptance, stresses the need for psychotherapists to manifest "nonjudgmental acceptance" of everyone who comes before them. Later in the book they will note that "there is a direct relationship between your ability to extend acceptance to others...and your self-acceptance" (p.57). 

Chapter V discusses Positive Regard, calling it "a major curative factor in any approach to therapy" (p. 43). What does it look like concretely? The authors suggest that a psychotherapist shows positive regard for patients in "a commitment to their well-being and best interests" (p.44). Towards the end of the chapter they caution that this must be finely "titrated" depending on patient and circumstance. This is especially true--as I have noted in previous entries on here--with patients having psychotic or schizophrenic disorders. With them, excessive or even moderate expressions of positive regard can be taken as serious threats, provoking unexpected and unhelpful reactions. 

Chapter VI, Genuineness, may be found in such qualities as "spontaneity, humour, and vulnerability," all of which aid in building and strengthening the working alliance. 

Also in this chapter--though, alas, without citing him--they authors refer to the need, precisely to maintain your genuineness as a psychotherapist, to deal with negative feelings towards patients, which D.W. Winnicott famously called "Hate in the Counter-Transference." This remains my favourite of DWW's papers, and I have written about it in several places.  

Chapter seven, Focus, looks at the importance of setting goals that both psychotherapist and patient agree to as a way of staying on track and strengthening the working alliance. (Chapter XII will note the common finding that ruptures in the working alliance are associated with poorer outcomes for psychotherapy. But these are rarely irreparable, and the very act of openly repairing such breaches can itself strengthen the alliance new.) 

In addition, goals remind both parties that this is not just an ordinary sympathetic chat, which one can get without payment over some tea with a close friend. As my first supervisor drilled into me, the very fact that money is involved (however regrettable that may be, and however much that disturbs some of us!) means that you can never be friends with your patients. It also means that you need a treatment plan, but not one carved in stone. It can and should be revisited on a regular basis to see if we are on track, or if we need to make changes, or to consider moving towards termination--or, in a perhaps better formulation I recently came across, discontinuation of services.

Focus also helps with the ever-present and universal problem of ambivalence. The authors review the evidence to indicate how unhelpful it is to push too far and too fast for change when ambivalence has manifested itself. Your job, rather, is to help your patients talk themselves into change. For some, getting past this ambivalence is all that is necessary: the patient is then off to the races and requires little help. Others, however, may require different skills and assistance from you once they start pursuing change seriously. 

Still others may need neutrality from you, or you may deliberately choose that for a variety of reasons. This is my own default position, influenced as I am by psychoanalysis and its very high respect for patient freedom, perhaps most sharply captured by Bion's famous counsel to the psychotherapist to begin every session "without memory and desire" so as to avoid unduly pushing the patient in one direction or another. I do not find a literal and strict interpretation of Bion entirely feasible in most cases, but it remains a useful counsel of perfection as it were. 

In all cases, a fine balance must be struck: your job is not to carry patients across the finish line of change, nor to ignore their efforts to get there. And these authors also have a high respect for patient autonomy (p.78) which needs to be set alongside shared goals for "when the goals of therapy are agreed upon, progress is much more likely" (p.79). 

Chapter VIII, Hope, reflects longstanding research (going back to the famous HARP studies first published in 1961) that if the psychotherapist is hopeful, even if the patient is not or cannot be just then, such hopefulness can have a very positive effect on outcomes. Hope here extends not just to the prospects of patient improvement, but also to your own attitude towards treatment: do you yourself believe that what you are doing, the treatment you are offering, is effective and important? Hopefulness is, they say, "contagious" and in some cases you can "lend...some of yours" to your patients if they cannot find it just yet. I have done this on occasion with severely traumatized patients feeling overwhelmed by their many challenges and not seeing much light on the horizon. (Of course, like all things, your extension of hope must be finely judged so that you are not foolishly prattling on about the hope of a total, immediate, and facile "recovery" to someone who has been, say, a heavy addict for thirty years, or a lifelong victim of sexual abuse.) 

Additional techniques here include asking patients to narrate past experiences where they had some success over a particular challenge. Another is to focus on their strengths. 

Hope for change can be seriously undermined, the authors note at the conclusion of this chapter, by a waiting list, for the research indicates that patients do exactly that: sit and wait. They do not, in other words, get started on any changes. This can be demoralizing and deflating of their discipline and desire to get started on change. For this reason, then, I here recall the words of an addictions psychologist I knew: you or your staff who answer the phones (e-mails, etc.) from people seeking services should give the warmest possible response with the utmost dispatch--within 24 hours at the most. People have often taken weeks, months, sometimes years to work up the courage to call for help, and you need to meet them at that moment wherever possible. Do not leave them hanging for days or weeks, even if you are very busy and cannot fit them in at that moment. 

Chapter IX, Evocation, focuses on a skill the authors see as uncommon and infrequently developed in the training of therapists. They do so based on the conviction that patient characteristics play a huge role in the success of therapy just as those of the clinician do. So the task of the therapist here is to evoke in the patient his or her own skills at self-healing. This is a position that starts from the assumption that the patient is in not just a state of deficit but also a position of having riches to offer they may not be aware of or able to access just yet. To access these riches, they may need your curiosity as a clinician to call them forth.

One way to help patients do this is summed up as O.A.R.S.: Open Questions, Affirmation, Reflection, and Summary. All this is to evoke that "change talk" that Miller first made famous in Motivational Interviewing. 

Chapter X, Offering Information and Advice, is one that, admittedly, I read with the greatest resistance, especially when flatly told by these authors that "Advising is a part of your job" (p.110). I make it very clear to my patients that I am not in the advice business. I think offering advice almost always infantilizing and counter-productive, and I loathe doing it. I am never so much a student of Erich Fromm as here in wanting people to live out their own freedom without fear and to find their own way. 

That said, these authors point to an example that I have myself done: recommending reading material. I once had a patient who for several months was manifesting great ambivalence, bordering on anxiety, between two very different career paths, each of which I thought she was romanticizing unduly while being very anxious about what she would miss in choosing one over another. So when she asked for something to read about this my mind shot immediately to Adam Phillips' Missing Out: In Praise of the Unlived Life, which I tried to mention as neutrally as possible so that my great enthusiasm for all of Phillips' works would not come out unduly. I made it clear--I think!--that I was simply reflecting how valuable I have found Phillips, and not telling her that she had to read him. But she turned up at the next session with the book under her arm, half of it read and heavily underlined in parts, and we had two or three sessions profitably discussing the book.

Chapter XI, The Far Side of Complexity, is a bit of a jumble as the authors seem clearly at pains to take avoid taking a clear stand on things bolder clinicians like Coltart have just come out and forthrightly spoken of as "faith; faith in ourselves and in this strange process which we daily create with our patients." For Miller and Moyers, they dance around such seemingly "spiritual" or "theological" language by invoking slogans like "simplicity on the far side of complexity" and talking about transcendence and shoveling in a few gratuitous bits of Buddhism that have too little context or elaboration to be useful. 

Coltart is again much better here in capturing this simplicity-within-complexity dynamic in describing the therapist as engaged in

sharply focusing, and scanning; complex involvement in feelings, and cool observation of them; close attention to the patient, and close attention to ourselves; distinguishing our own true feelings from subtle projections into us; communicating insight clearly, yet not imposing it; drawing constantly on resources of knowledge, yet being ready to know nothing for long periods; willing the best for our patients and ourselves, yet abandoning memory and desire; a kind of tolerant steadiness which holds us while we make innumerable, minute moral decisions, yet steering clear of being judgmental (Slouching Towards Bethlehem, p.119). 

Chapter XII stands at the start of Part III of Effective Psychotherapists, which, with the exception of the previous chapter, has so far been written with wonderful and admirable cogency and clarity, making this an ideal text for undergraduates or graduates alike. (I am very warmly recommending it to my students next semester in my Introduction to Counselling course.) 

This chapter, Developing Expertise, records the startling but simultaneously reassuring and "widely replicated finding that therapists' years of experience are unrelated to their actual expertise" (p.127). Left unsaid here is a tempting line of thought I might have developed about the need for more careful screening of students into training programs to see if some of the attributes discussed earlier in this book are in evidence or not. 

Also left unsaid here is any discussion about the centrality of the psychotherapist's own psychotherapy. Raising this point seems to generate a lot of controversy and resistance among some, for reasons which are not clear to me. I regard it as de rigueur that a psychotherapist must have done their own in-depth work. I know I could never do this myself without having spent years on the analytic couch, as I have done in three separate periods. Freud was right, in one of the last essays he wrote, "Analysis Terminable and Interminable," in seeing that one's own analytic therapy offers both skills and insights which are "not ceasing when it ends." But the gains may be limited, which is why he rightly goes on, later in that essay, to call for the therapist "periodically--at intervals of five years or so--[to] submit himself to analysis once more, without feeling ashamed of taking this step." 

In addition to one's own semi-regular therapy, Miller and Moyers argue there are things a clinician can do to improve in certain areas or to acquire or reinforce certain skills. These they treat under the heading of "deliberate practice" which has two components: some skill you very consciously focus on developing, and some supervision of it or feedback about it you also consciously cultivate and seek out.

The book concludes with Chapters XIII and XIV, which may be of some limited interest to academics teaching courses in psychotherapy and counseling, including courses in skills and techniques. 

Overall, the book is a very useful and up-to-date summary of what we know about Effective Psychotherapists and their clinical skills, and it is written in a way that allows its summaries of relevant and recent research to be made easily accessible to general readers, students, and scholars alike. 

How Much Light is in the SOLER System?

In discussing Neville Symington recently, I noted in passing his welcome comment about the importance of a therapist's office.

This is a question I spent some time investigating earlier this semester when one of our graduate classes introduced the so-called SOLER recommendations for doing therapy. (SOLER = Sitting Squarely while having an Open posture as you Lean in, maintain Eye contact, and have Relaxed body language.) 

I confess upon reading this that I immediately had questions, and so spent a happy few days ransacking the literature going back to the early 1970s to see what it said, and to see if there is a consistent evidence base justifying all these arrangements as a feature of a consulting room. It turns out--as they say in some Scottish trials--that the case is "not proven," or at least not proven to any degree sufficient to convince me. 

I do not pretend that what follows is an exhaustive literature review, but I can report the following: One early study (Broekmann and Moller, 1973) yielded ambiguous results, in part because, the authors say, their 30 randomly assigned test subjects were regular students, not patients in therapy. This study found that in some cases students preferred chairs side-by-side, rather than facing each other squarely, but in other situations preferred chairs facing each other squarely but with a large table in between them. 

Another old study found that room arrangements differed considerably between patients and therapists: “clients had different preferences for seating arrangements than did counselors. In general, clients preferred spatial arrangements that were more protected than those preferred by the counselors” (Haase and DiMattia, 1976, p.414). Once again, however, both groups of subjects in this experiment were American university students (and all men), not those in therapy, and they were assigned very particular cognitive tasks of learning and conditioning not always found in therapy, so I am not sure how useful these results are. Still, it did uncover that a larger room consistently invited longer verbalization by the subjects than a smaller room. But as for furniture and its arrangements, the results uncovered merely “a marginally significant effect due to furniture arrangements” (p. 419). The authors then conclude that “It would be desirable to replicate this study with a group of actual clients…in addition to analogue studies.”

Further analogue studies from the same time (e.g., Chaikin et al 1976) emphasized the need for a consulting room to be a “warm, intimate” place to facilitate greater self-disclosure. Another focused primarily on the therapist’s attire and office decorations, but said nothing about furniture and its arrangements (Amira and Abramowitz, 1979). More recent research (e.g., Miwa and Hanyu, 2006) also focuses on lighting and decorations while, again, saying little about furniture and its arrangement.

A 2011 study (Nasar and Devlin), also with students, uncovered several interesting findings: a warmer, more intimate space consists largely of using more classical wood materials rather than colder and harder steel and concrete, or brick; plants are very often a encouraging sign of vitality; the display of diplomas almost universally increases perceptions of the clinician’s trustworthiness and credibility; and a messy desk is rated more positively than an excessively neat one (which is seen as somewhat stiff and cold, or as Freud might say, anal retentive!). 

A significant difference in this study is that “We sampled real environments: 30 offices used by psychotherapists” (p.311). Test subjects were shown real photographs of offices, mostly in Manhattan. From this it emerged that subjects ranked matters thus: “Neatness and chair comfort were rated as most important, followed by order, space, style, and color. The first two items were judged significantly more important than were the rest” (p. 317). It’s important to note here that the “chair” in question is the therapist’s chair, pictures of which were shown to subjects in this study—the discussion of furniture here was limited to this one chair only. As they note in conclusion, “Although the therapist’s chair was the focus of the photograph that respondents viewed…client seating could be the focus of future study.”

A 2013 study (Devlin et al), using the same method as the study just mentioned from 2011, this time asked a cross-cultural group of subjects to look at pictures of the therapist’s chair and office surrounding it. Here it was found that among student populations in the US, Turkey, and Vietnam (more than 1/3 of whom had been to therapy at least once) there was consensus on things like colour, neatness, perceived “softness” and “orderliness” of the offices, but no substantial comment on furniture arrangement beyond noting that “participants rated chair comfort as highest in importance, and neatness and orderliness among the most important attributes in influencing their judgments” (p.15). Once again, the reference here is to the therapist’s chair only, and nothing was said about its position in the room.

Another 2011 study, a qualitative survey of practicing psychologists, has yielded fascinating data into how they see their offices, how they arrange them, and how strongly they have a desire to have control over such elements. The authors began by admitting that “psychologists’ offices have been largely absent from contemporary theoretical and methodological discussions of therapeutic environments.” They note that “in general, the therapeutic setting should be a holding environment; psychologists and their offices should provide comfortable and secure environments within which clients feel free to communicate sensitive information” (Watkins and Anthony, 2011, p.2). That use of “holding environment” is of course a signature idea of object-relations theory, which these authors explicitly reference several times, especially the works of Winnicott and Klein. I found it very encouraging that they admitted “If necessary, a few psychologists were even willing to rearrange furniture for specific clients” (p.8).

Three other studies recognize a lack of data. Gass (1984) has admitted with commendable candor that “Recommendations that concern the seating arrangement in therapy are based more on intuition than on empirical research,” which accords with my initial suspicions (see below).

In one of the longest and most comprehensive studies I’ve yet found, surveying a wide variety of clinicians (psychiatrists, social workers, counsellors, etc.) in many contexts, the author (Backhaus, 2008) noted that research over the last forty years has rarely focused on arrangements of furniture and related details in consulting rooms before going on to argue that “the seating arrangement in the therapeutic environment is perhaps the most controversial aspect of the physical environment of the therapy room. Based on results from several studies, there does not appear to be one recommended method for seating arrangement” (p.22). Whence comes this controversy she mentions? The author does not say. But it is noteworthy, and reassuring, that there is not one prescribed arrangement everybody must universally follow.

She does go on to tip her hand somewhat, nothing that “in intimate situations, both parties often sit next to each other versus across the room from one another” (p.23). Her most valuable suggestion, to my mind, is that clinicians should be “offering clients several seating options including chairs that can be easily moved” (p.22). I think this is extremely wise: flexibility and a focus on what the person prefers should be uppermost considerations in the design of a consulting room.

The most recent research by Jackson confirms the gap first noted by Gass in 1984. Jackson (2018) admits that “Despite its importance, the subject of the therapist's office has been largely absent from contemporary literature, with a few exceptions.” 

Interestingly, she does quote a 1988 book, Psychotherapy Tradecraft: The Technique and Style of Doing Therapy, by a former APA President Theodore Blau, who does have some concrete recommendations over furniture and its arrangement. She quotes him as having “encouraged thoughtful seating options that ‘consider comfort and convenience,’ and that ‘the most comfortable and orthopaedically correct seating possible is strongly recommended in order to avoid back problems’ for the therapist.” She also later avers to “the use of chairs that are moveable or large enough to allow clients to choose their positions, providing a sense of control over their environment” (p. 235). Once again, then, we see there is encouragement to be flexible and have one’s furniture be portable. I find this exactly right and most encouraging. 

Beyond peer-reviewed journals other reflections (e.g., Saari, 2002) remain vague about clinical environments, as do APA  and a handful of other professional blogs I have seen, which talk in generalities about office design and patient-therapist arrangements, always emphasizing that patient needs come first, which is exactly right. 

In sum, then, and putting this preliminary literature review together, then, and recognizing that it doesn’t pretend to be exhaustive but I think fairly representative nonetheless, I have thus far found very little specific, explicit, concrete, and repeated evidence (or even discussion) justifying SOLER. 

Given that I’ve not found much evidence so far, I can’t help but return to my original suspicion that perhaps SOLER arrangements began as a personal preference (from someone like Rogers perhaps?) that has then been simply copied by others without much thought or research precisely in the same manner as Freud’s famous couch was almost mindlessly copied with no comment, let alone deeper reflection or empirical study, in the psychoanalytic literature for the better part of a century. 

Only very recently, in fact, have two fascinating books been published looking critically at the role of couches: Kravis, 2017; and Gerald, 2019. He himself only justified the couch by saying that he could not stand being looked at for 8 hours a day, but otherwise wrote nothing about the couch, which seems to have been a holdover from his early attempts at using hypnotherapy.

Is it possible, then, that SOLER arrangements remain as undertheorized and under-researched as Freud’s couch? Gass, Backhaus, and Jackson all strongly suggest as much. I think, therefore, that there are strong arguments to be made about alternate arrangements, some of which, some of the time, for some people, may well prove to be more therapeutically effective than SOLER.

Here are my arguments and concerns with the presuppositions in the literature:

Constantly facing people square on presupposes that they want you to do that, that they are comfortable with such an arrangement, and that their progress in therapy will be helped, not hindered, by such an arrangement. I do not make those assumptions, and would want, as part of an intake process or after a preliminary session, to invite people to express their preferences and, at the next and subsequent sessions, to position themselves as they wish. If therapists are there to serve patients, then surely these latter need to have some choice as to posture and position in the consulting room.

Why do I say that? Four reasons. First, as Judith Herman’s Trauma and Recovery and other books in traumatology suggest, severely traumatized patients often feel like they have few or no choices, and feel profoundly disempowered. Giving them even modest choice and power to decide things, she says, is important in therapy.

Second, does SOLER presuppose a Western audience—and even within such an audience presuppose that every “Westerner” is comfortable with such an arrangement? Do we know if other cultures would be equally at home with such an arrangement? I've found little evidence that this question has even occurred to previous researchers apart from the Devlin et al study discussed above. Thus I have to wonder: Is it not possible that some cultures would find a SOLER arrangement if not threatening then at the very least considerably uncomfortable, perhaps so much so that therapeutic progress is attenuated?

Third, my own experience as an analysand of course enters here. I found the couch very helpful in recounting especially bizarre dreams or traumatic memories. These things were hard enough to vocalize to begin with, but I’m quite sure I’d never have gotten into them if I had to face my analyst. (Indeed, for our first three intake sessions, when facing her in a chair, I danced around a lot of stuff, speaking only in extremely vague generalities because I couldn’t talk about certain things while having to make eye contact. Once on the couch, however, it was easier to begin, however gingerly, to wade into deep and dark waters.)

Fourth, I have had difficult conversations with students on campus while walking side-by-side and not facing each other, as well as with my own son, neither of which would, I wager, have gone successfully and smoothly if my interlocutor was forced to look me in the eye the whole time.  

For all these reasons, then, I would invite people in my consulting room to one of three arrangements. First would be the SOLER arrangement—two chairs face to face. (Some people, I know, really do prefer that arrangement.) Second would be to have an additional chair placed beside my own, both facing the same direction, slightly angled and with a modest gap (e.g., small table) between them. Thus a person could choose to sit either across from or beside me. The third option would be a couch. And I would invite people to make use of both chairs and the couch as they saw fit, without requiring that they be consistent. Some days they might feel the need to lie down; others to sit but not face me; and still others, to see me and know I’m there. I'm quite happy with their doing whatever they need to from session to session. 

There are, I must confess in conclusion, some perhaps more "selfish" reasons connected to the fact that I know my own posture could be misinterpreted, and that my own tolerance for leaning in and constantly facing someone would be diminished if not exhausted after a time. For me, sitting with hands behind my head, or arms crossed, are often postures for me not of being closed, but of being more physically comfortable and thus freed up to listen more carefully. I find that when trying to listen more deeply with my “third ear” (Reik 1948) to hear what else the person might be saying unconsciously or trying to avoid saying, I sometimes find it very helpful not to lean in and maintain eye contact, but to sit back and look off into the distance or even close my eyes, trying to catch, in Eliot’s lovely words,

The voice of the hidden waterfall
And the children in the apple-tree
Not known, because not looked for
But heard, half-heard, in the stillness
Between two waves of the sea.


++++++++++++++++++



REFERENCES:


Amira, S. and Abramowitz, S.I. (1979). Therapeutic attraction as a function of therapist attire and office furnishings. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1979, 47, 198-200.

Backhaus, K.L. (2008). Client and therapist perspectives on the importance of the physical environment of the therapy room: A mixed methods study. Doctoral dissertation at Texas Women’s University. 

Broekmann, N.C. and Moller, A.T. (1973). Preferred seating position and distance in various situations. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 20, 504-508.

Devlin, A.S. Nasar, J.L., and Cubukcu, Ebru (2013). Students’ impressions of psychotherapists’ offices: cross-cultural comparisons. Environment and Behavior, 20, 1–26.

Devlin, A. S., and Nasar, J. L. (2012). Impressions of psychotherapists’ offices: Do therapists and clients agree? Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 43, 118-122.

Gass, C.S. (1984). Therapeutic influence as a function of therapist attire and the seating arrangement in an initial interview. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 40, 52-57.

Gerald, Mark (2019). In the Shadow of Freud’s Couch: Portraits of Psychoanalysts in Their Offices. London: Routledge.

Jackson, Devlin (2018). Aesthetics and the psychotherapist’s office. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 74, 233-238.

Kravis, Nathan (2017). The Couch: a Repressed History of the Analytic Couch from Plato to Freud. Boston: MIT Press.

Nassar, J. and Devlin, A. (2011). Impressions of psychotherapists’ offices. Journal of Counseling Psychology 58, 310 –320.

Reik, Theodore (1948). Listening with the Third Ear: the Inner Experience of a Psychoanalyst. New York: Farrar Strauss & Co.

Saari, Carolyn (2002). The Environment: Its Role in Psychosocial Functioning and Psychotherapy. New York: Columbia  University Press.

Yoshiko Miwa, and Kazunori Hanyu (2006). The effects of interior design on communication and  impressions of a counselor in a counseling room. Environment and Behavior, 38, 484-502.

Watkins, N.J. and Anthony, K.H. (2011). The design of psychologists’ offices: A qualitative evaluation of environment-function fit.