Posts

Showing posts with the label psychotherapy

A Note on Karon and Teixeria on Dynamic Therapy for Schizophrenia

That wonderful site, www.freepsychotherapybooks.org, has many riches you should peruse. Those include numerous volumes on schizophrenia. I have downloaded several such volumes and will get to them eventually.

I began with "Psychoanalytic Therapy of Schizophrenia," written by Bertram Karon and Michael Teixeria, which was originally published in 1995 as the fourth chapter of a collection edited by Jacques Barber and Paul Chrits-Christoph, Dynamic Therapies For Psychiatric Disorders (PDF). 

Some of the material in this chapter will be familiar to those who have read Psychotherapy of Schizophrenia: The Treatment of Choice by Bertram P. Karon and Gary R. VandenBos, which I discussed in detail here. In fact, I would recommend starting with just this chapter, which gives a good summary of the key points from Karon's much longer book. Let me sum up some of the insights from this chapter:

The first section is an historical review of the literature, starting with Freud, whom they describe as having had a "guarded hopefulness" about the treatment of schizophrenia. This, of course, runs contrary to the usual summary of Freud's view that schizophrenia and psychosis were beyond the help of psychoanalytic methods. 

However, having recently read his 1924 essays "Neurosis and Psychosis" and "The Loss of Reality in Neurosis and Psychosis," I do find he is indeed guardedly hopeful in both places in ways I had not previously encountered. (Both essays, and some other even more interesting ones, are collected in General Psychological Theory: Papers on Metapsychology, a used copy of which I found in an Indianapolis bookstore recently.) Karon and Teixeria report Jung as being even more hopeful, believing that it can be "completely treated and cured by psychotherapeutic means" (p.5). 

This gives rise to an historical survey, through the 1990s, of primarily American attempts at understanding the aetiology of schizophrenia as well as attempts at supporting the families of schizophrenics. We then turn to a focus on common features of the disorder, and common myths about it.

Features:

Hallucinations: These are noted as being (as others have said) wide-awake dreams, and the psychotherapist should respond to them as one does with nocturnal dreams reported by non-psychotic patients: by asking for their associations to the dream, and then offering a possible interpretation of some of the symbolism, making sure to stress that the latter is merely one's best clinical judgment and not infallible!

Delusions: Do not make the assumption that all delusions are fixed and unchanging. They are very often dynamic and significant parts can shift over time. Pay attention to the shifts! 

Interpersonal Relations: With Fairbairn these authors several times assert that schizophrenia is an interpersonal disorder and must be treated as such: "people only get sick in relationships and therefore can only get better within a relationship" (p.34). 

Goals:

The authors list a full dozen treatment goals, some of which are unique to this group of patients but many of which are common to everybody. On this latter point they share Freud's view that the two primary goals of all therapy are an increased ability to work and to love, and to enjoy doing both. 

Therapeutic Characteristics and Techniques: 

These authors share the view of others noted on here that the psychotherapist must be careful in seeking to be a giver, not a taker. And strikingly one of the most important if paradoxical areas for this to manifest itself is in the question of delusions. The patient may well be very attached to his delusions and other psychotic symptoms. Why might that be so, for it seems so odd and counter-productive. But we are reminded that these symptoms are compromise formations having considerable utility--they are "the best psychodynamic solutions the patient is capable of before treatment" (p.34).

Empathic Vision of the Terror:

It is important for the psychotherapist to make as much effort as possible to see the world as the patient sees it, and this extends perhaps above all to the delusions and hallucinations, which have meaning: "the most important thing for a therapist to remember is that every symptom of schizophrenia is meaningful and embedded in the life history of the patient. There is a difference between meaninglessness and obscure meaning" (p.37). In other words, just because the meaning is not manifest and obvious to you, there is no reason to sneer at and dismiss it as irrational nonsense!

In all this material there is to be found across the schizophrenic's vision of the world stark terror, and the psychotherapist must make every effort, repeatedly, to allay this. These authors report--as others have--that one very useful way to do this is by assuring the patients at the outset that whatever else may happen, the therapist will not allow the patient to be killed. 

Tolerating Uncertainty: 

As others have reported--including, with non-psychotic patients, Nina Coltart--the psychotherapist of psychosis and schizophrenia has to be prepared to tolerate long stretches of not knowing what exactly is happening or whether things are helping. This is not only to be expected in this line of treatment, but is itself a useful experience for the patient: 

A therapist who can tolerate uncertainty is a good model for the patient. It is useful to tell patients when they complain that therapy is making them confused, "Good. You are not sick because you are confused. You are sick because you are certain of things which may not be true" (p.39).

That last line, incidentally, bears not a little resemblance to a common theme of Adam Phillips' many books, where he notes how many of us are twisted up within narratives taken to be true that may not in fact be--or at least not wholly.

Forming the Working Alliance:

"Begin as you mean to go on" is not a bad summary for Karon and Teixeria's thoughts here. Start the intake as you would with any other patient, inquiring as to what is wrong and how you might help. This is usually enough with the schizophrenic to get them going. 

As you move into a discussion about what psychotherapy is and how you operate, they recommend that you say "All I have to offer you is understanding, but that is a really great deal" (p. 44). They also recommend you note, and repeat as necessary, that the patient has total freedom to talk about anything. Thus you need to seek to allay the common fears of such patients that the clinician will disbelieve or denigrate the patient's beliefs and visions. Equally you need to allay the fear that talking about an emotion will lead to acting on it, an especially terrifying worry for many. 

Praise What and Where You Can:

If, in your discussion of delusions as waking dreams, the patient presents an especially compelling--if manifestly unrealistic--interpretation, these authors suggest the judicious use of praise: "That is a brilliant explanation" (p.48) is one phrase they recommend. You are not thereby saying the patient's delusion or even explanation are true, but only that they might in fact be highly developed for compelling reasons that do make a lot of sense to the patient in his or her present plight. 

This, of course, is just another way of saying "Do not challenge." I have found both counsels effective in my limited experience: when I switched from challenging an elaborate delusion (which resulted in an abrupt shutting down by the patient) but instead praised it--for the patient had clearly put a lot of thought into it, down to very fine gradations of colours worn by, and highly specific grades of authority given to, some of the demons reported in the delusion--the conversation continued to flow rather fulsomely and trust was regained. 

On Play and Enjoyment and Laughter in Psychotherapy

  As Arthur Leonoff commented in his necrology for Dr Louise Carignan, who was my psychoanalyst for seven years, she had a very memorable and infectious laugh. I don't remember what provoked it on one particular afternoon while I was lying on her couch, but the memory of that laugh has stayed with me more than twenty years later. It helped me realize that psychoanalysis and psychotherapy were not solely about solemnly entering into deep, dark waters of trauma, but should allow for occasions of laughter and enjoyment. 

This is a theme I first found in the great Nina Coltart, about whom I wrote here at some length, reflecting my longstanding gratitude to her. Her book Slouching Towards Bethlehem was what inspired me to seek out Dr Carignan in the first place, and in that book she stoutly and rightly insists that patient and therapist should be able to find humour in situations and therefore to laugh together.

More recently, I have been hugely indebted to Adam Phillips, including his recent book The Cure for Psychoanalysis. It is in that book (about which more another time) that he reminds me of what Winnicott (whose biography Phillips wrote more than thirty years ago now) said about the role of playing and enjoying in psychotherapy. 

Though I wrote earlier this year a few jottings on D.W. Winnicott on the fiftieth anniversary of his death, I had not then quite managed to finish Playing and Reality, which I now have thanks to Phillips drawing on it in his recent book, where he says that "what appeals to me about Winnicott is his wish to enjoy the patient's company." Just so. 

Reading DWW is always such a wonderful experience. You never have to worry about being bamboozled by theory or assaulted by polemics, or confused by turgid and abstruse sentences. I really do have the feeling, through Phillips' portrait and others I have read over the years, that you could indeed see DWW making and enjoying a cup of tea with his patients. This still comes through even today in his writing, many of whose basic insights seem to age really well. (I have recently found some of his writings in Through Paediatrics to Psychoanalysis on the possible meaning of adolescent stealing helpful to thinking through a very difficult case I am involved with clinically.) 

In Playing and Reality, DWW stoutly opens his third chapter by insisting: "Psychotherapy has to do with two people playing together." He goes on to say that if the patient is incapable of playing, then this must be the primary clinical task: to help them get to the point where they can play. In other words, modifying a famous Freudian saying, I would say "Where inhibition was, there shall playing be!" Or--if you will indulge me one more--modifying an equally famous saying of Ferenczi, the patient is not cured by playing but is cured when s/he can play (and do so, presumably, on his or her own). 

Later in the chapter, DWW says that health can be defined by the extent to which one is capable of playing, and that such playing "is itself a therapy." But in a clinical setting, there is a particular type of playing: "the playing has to be spontaneous and not compliant or acquiescent if psychotherapy is to be done." It cannot be coerced, in other words, but creative (a word DWW makes much of throughout this book) and always free. 

This, of course, requires certain things from the therapist, and here DWW is again equally direct: "If the therapist cannot play, then he is not suitable for the work." Therapists can also wreck the play of therapy, DWW warns, if they behave like experts who understand all the possible configurations of a game and act from this position of presumed omniscience instead of being at one with the patient in not knowing in advance how the game will play out. 

This, we know from several sources, is very much how DWW was with his patients, not just because he reports this to us, and his wife also noted this in a moving and important essay she wrote after his death, but also from some of his analysands including, perhaps most famously, Marion Milner, who charmingly recounts of DWW that was "on excellent terms with his primary process"! 

It is of course common today for therapists to have websites on which they advertise their philosophy of treatment, location, fees, etc. But in all my perusing of these, I have never once come across anybody who says that "Psychotherapy has to do with two people playing together." Imagine having that on a banner atop your website, or framed on your waiting room wall! 

Nor have I seen any self-descriptions by therapists today that they are on excellent terms with their primary process! Their websites sometimes groan under the weight of degrees and credentials, yes, and additional certification and training in whatever the acronym du jour is--certainly. But to advertise oneself as being on excellent terms with one's primary process?

If we cannot be playful and find the work enjoyable, and laugh at ourselves and with our patients, then it seems hardly likely that we will be able to keep at it for long or to do it very well. Thank God we have the witness of Donald Winnicott even fifty years after his death to save us from such ponderousness and to remind us of playing and enjoying not just outside our consulting rooms but within them. 

Louis Cozolino on the Making of a Therapist

I don't remember exactly how I came across Louis Cozolino's The Making of a Therapist: A Practical Guide for the Inner Journey, but I am very glad and grateful that I did. He has written an extremely useful book in a cogent and accessible fashion. I would be very tempted to use it if I ever teach a course on, say, introductions to counselling and therapy. 

He begins by noting that would-be therapists need to be encouraged not to "stay above the neck" in how they relate to their patients: "the more fearless we become in the exploration of our inner worlds, the greater our self-knowledge and our ability to help our clients" (xvi). Such inner exploration is necessary because that world is a crucial tool: "the private personal world of the therapist is, in fact, one of our most important tools" (xviii). The fact that this is so little taught today, Cozolino says, is a great loss to all concerned. And we mustn't resist doing this, for, as he says a little later, "to accept our clients, we have to first learn to accept ourselves. This can be the biggest challenge of all" (15).  

His first chapter reiterates what I have seen so often, and recently written about, in Nina Coltart: the therapist, for much of the time, must live with not knowing, not being certain, not having clear ideas of what is going on. This is not to be shunned or feared. 

Arranging the Consulting Room:

Chapter II has some very practical tips on getting centred in order to get started. He says that one must pay attention to one's consulting room and its set-up to ensure a comfortable, calm, mindful environment for you as well as your patient. I wrote rather at length about such matters here. He says it's best not to have chairs directly facing one another, and to give people options for sitting, asking them from time to time about how they feel being in the consulting room with you. He also says there's nothing wrong with modifying arrangements if people need or request it.

Communicating:

As you are going about your day, schedule yourself to allow for breaks and to ensure you are not rushing. Equally or even more important: do not rush to fill in gaps, but allow for silence. When you do talk, keep it simple and short. This good advice, much confirmed by my recent supervisors, led me to adapt something I heard in another context:

  • Be blunt
  • Be brief
  • Be quiet. 

Maintaining the Tension:

Good therapy, Cozolino says, is always going to find itself stretched between several poles:

  • Nurture and Challenge
  • Comfort and Stress
  • Affect and Cognition

In addition, it should have the goal of increased affect regulation and the creation of new narratives about the self. 

Treatment Plans:

These will flow out of your theoretical orientation, he says, and are constructed backwards, from goals to interventions. Keep them clear, straightforward, and open to revision in dialogue with your patient.

Notes: 

Keep them very short and say nothing critical that you would not want the patient to read.

Loving Defenses, Patiently:

What Cozolino writes about appreciating the role of resistance and defenses puts me in mind of Auden's poem "In Memory of Sigmund Freud," which I love, especially these lines:

he would have us remember most of all 
to be enthusiastic over the night,
     not only for the sense of wonder
   it alone has to offer, but also

because it needs our love. With large sad eyes
its delectable creatures look up and beg
     us dumbly to ask them to follow:
   they are exiles who long for the future

that lives in our power, they too would rejoice
if allowed to serve enlightenment like him.

One thing I have realized over the past year is that we must come even to love the defenses for they once served a useful purpose that has since become maladaptive. Cozolino says that if patients see your appreciation of their defenses, they "will be more wiling to explore alternative ways of being" (76). All this will be slow-going with, he says, some "backsliding." 

Resistances, too, have their rewards, not least because they often point quite clearly and directly to what is most painful and difficult that might hitherto have been closed off to and hidden from us. This may also be true of conflicts in the therapy. Don't be defensive about defenses, about conflicts, about resistances. That will serve nothing and nobody. To launch a frontal attack on defenses is to ensure they deepen. 

Negative Therapeutic Reaction and the Death Drive:

Cozolino has clearly been influenced by the psychodynamic traditions, but he wears them very lightly. He raises "the very success of therapy" will unsettle some people and cause regression, or even destruction and early departure. All this is, he says, a "common occurrence" (119). (Freud certainly saw it, not least in Beyond the Pleasure Principle.)

Counter-Transference and the Desire to Sack:

Cozolino offers some helpful advice in sorting out the desire to fire or sack a patient. This may be legitimate--you are a bad fit, or lack the skills for this particular disorder, or are in an impasse. But it might also be caused by the patient who needs to try to get you to fire him or her, creating, yet again, their past experience of abandonment. This requires careful discernment on your part, and perhaps some supervision if necessary.

In his ninth chapter, he introduces the very useful image and concept of shuttling. This is "up into your head, and down into your body" as you monitor counter-transference reactions. You shuttle from mind to body, and then from you to your patient and back again. He offers very concrete guidance here, saying you should do this if you've felt disconnected, or been tuned out, confused by what the patients is said, or fearful or anxious. He often shares the results of these shuttlings, especially if a particular strong feeling or image surfaces. Sometimes these can provoke really stunning responses; at other times they miss their mark. In any case, he allows the patient to "accept, reject, modify, or ignore" the results of the shuttling, saying that if it is rejected, just let it go because hanging on to it will not serve any purpose.

Dreams: The Royal Road to Whose Unconscious?

Cozolino has a brief section on the use of dreams, noting that patient's dreams are of course useful and important, but so are the therapist's. He gives a compelling example of how one dream of his enabled him to pick up on a deeply buried part of his patient's life, endlessly denied, and eventually nudge this trauma out into the open.

Wordiness Should Make You Wary:

Patients will try to recreate other relationships in the therapeutic relationship. One such will be the excessively wordy person who appears to be describing things--even feelings, or traumatic memories--in great, and greatly wordy, detail. This can be a trap and so Cozolino says we must not "mistake a barrage of words for openness and vulnerability" (143). 

The Vocation and its Enjoyment:

Cozolino ends this excellent book where he began, saying that your self-acceptance (and self-care, which he stresses in the penultimate chapter) will be key to your flourishing in the vocation of therapy, which must not be allowed to become all drudgery but should be an occasion (as Coltart and before her Winnicott above all said) where patient and therapist can enjoy one another (at least some of the time). 

Healing Sexually Betrayed Boys and Men

Last year I reviewed a manuscript for Routledge and in exchange for my labours took my remuneration in books, including a copy of this book: Richard B. Gartner, Healing Sexually Betrayed Men and Boys: Treatment for Sexual Abuse, Assault, and Trauma (Routledge, 2018). 

It is the second volume, a companion to Understanding the Sexual Betrayal of Boys and Men: The Trauma of Sexual Abuse (Routledge, 2017).

I have not read the 2017 volume, but on the strength of the second, I will be doing so.

Healing Sexually Betrayed Men and Boys is a very rich collection, only some of which I can hope to convey here. It certainly belongs in the hands of every man or boy who has been victimized, but will be equally valuable to their partners and family members, and of course to clinicians of all traditions. There is a great deal of solid research conveyed here as well as some pioneering programs, and reflections of those pioneering clinicians themselves. 

The book is divided into four sections, with a total of fifteen chapters. Most are written by US clinicians, but several are written by clinicians in Canada, including one, Rick Goodwin, based in Ottawa, where I did my initial training in psychology and underwent psychoanalysis. So his chapter was of special interest to me.

The first section looks at general and global issues in treating men who have been abused. The second looks at focused treatments, including a new program, Weekend of Recovery, and a resource-rich website to which it is connected, MaleSurvivor.org. The third section, "Women in the Picture," looks at female therapists working with male survivors as well as female partners of the same; there is also a section on same-sex partners and their unique challenges. In this section also is a chapter on covert seduction, about which more in a moment. 

The fourth and final section is a rare look at perpetrators who are also survivors/victims, and the very great difficulties that arise when trying to find placements for such men to be treated. I will return to this again later. Each section, and nearly every chapter, also contains often harrowing case material of patients the authors have treated over the years. 

Let me just highlight three chapters while, again, encouraging all those with interest in this area to read the whole book. 

The fourth chapter, co-authored by Howard Fradkin and Jim Struve, "Empowering Male Survivors to Heal through Community and Peer Connections," contains a new model that I have found fascinating. Based on their belief that group work is a crucial adjunct to individual psychotherapy, the authors proposed, plan, and have helped host Weekends of Recovery around the world since 2001. "While not considered therapy, the weekends often have therapeutic benefits," the authors say (102). In this regard, A good bit of the underlying philosophy, they say, comes from that landmark book we all know and love, The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy by Irvin Yalom and Molyn Leszcz; their sixth edition was published just a month ago. There is much here, it seems to me, that would lend itself to Catholic churches borrowing and adapting for similar purposes as parishes and victims try to heal from the never-ending abuse in their midst, which I have addressed at length elsewhere. 

Chapter 11, "Covert Seduction and its Effect on Boys and Men," by Kenneth Adams is deeply interesting, raising a concept I have never heard before: covert seduction, where boys are used emotionally and sexually without actual physical sexual contact in most cases: "you can be sexually abused without being sexually touched" (214). One example of this he focuses on later in the chapter is exposure to pornography, especially at an early age. Other examples include bathing and toilet rituals as well as expecting boys to fulfill emotional and sexual needs of their mothers in the absence, or as rivals to, husbands and fathers. 

The damage this can leave is very real, serious, and long-lasting in many cases, resulting in guilt, schizoid-like detachment, shame, ongoing struggles to detach from the covertly incestuous family member, etc. In therapy, Adams cautions several times, these victims will often be the ideal patients--docile, compliant, reporting positive effects and results. All this is in fact a sign of their pathology: they have learned compliance, docility, and the importance of manifesting positive results as a result of their abuse. 

The last section is useful in highlighting some of the challenges that come from men who were themselves victims before going on to be perpetrators. The authors cite research indicating that this number is much lower than is sometimes portrayed, suggesting it is around 12% of abuse victims who go on to become perpetrators (a number borrowed from Anna Salter's very useful groundbreaking book Predators). Additionally this section contains a helpful typology of abusers, and a section of female abusers as well. 

All told, Richard Gartner and his contributors to Healing Sexually Betrayed Men and Boys: Treatment for Sexual Abuse, Assault, and Trauma have given us many insights (each chapter's lengthy bibliography is very valuable indeed) in this rich and helpful book. I know I shall be returning to it regularly. 

The Therapist's Therapy

When psychoanalysis came to Canada, it retained more of its European and originally Freudian ideas and practices in some respects than it did when it came to the United States. One glaring example of this is in training requirements: Americans until recently required medical training before application to analytic training; Canadians never did. 

When I was an undergraduate in psychology in Ottawa in the 90s seriously contemplating analytic training, I knew I was not cut out for, nor did I have any interest in attending, medical school. Fortunately, following the model Freud first put forth in The Question of Lay Analysis, I knew there was an open path for me, allowing me to combine my scholarly interests with the clinical: I would obtain a doctorate--whether in history, psychology, religious studies, or possibly philosophy was not clear to me then--and then train as an analyst at the institute in Montreal. Many others had done this before me and it was long since commonplace in Canada as across most of Europe and elsewhere. In that book, Freud in fact spoke of the ideal analyst as being neither a priest nor a physician but a "secular pastoral worker," a very curious phrase which was, and remains, inspiring to me. 

The other requirement, of course, universally adopted--even in the US--was that analysts had first to be analysands, and thus undergo a training analysis. 

Moreover, Freud recognized very late in life, in "Analysis Terminable and Interminable," the need for ongoing treatment. Freud has reassuring words when he counsels that "Every analyst ought periodically himself to submit to analysis, at intervals of, say, five years, without any feeling of shame in so doing." (One of the things I admire about Nina Coltart, is her regular reminders throughout her books of the need for analysts and therapists to go back into therapy even occasionally or to "get a bit of supervision" as she puts it flatly if the counter-transference is getting out of hand or other difficulties arise.) 

Since returning to the clinical field more recently, and this time in the United States, I am frankly amazed not just at how long it took American institutes to admit more than just physicians, but to a broader phenomenon across the entire mental health field and outside of analytic institutes: the lack of any sort of requirement for personal therapy on the part of those who train to be therapists in other programs--clinical social workers, mental health counsellors, etc. 

I am aware, having read more than a few stories of abuse, that the requirement for therapy necessitates very careful handling so that it does not end up reinforcing certain existing ideological prejudices or power structures while hiding behind clinical concerns. Not unlike certain professors holding up their doctoral students because of "political" disagreements with other members of the jury (which I have seen first hand), certain analysts could hold up certain trainees as being "insufficiently analyzed" or "resistant" when in fact these trainees just disagreed with their analyst, or were more inclined to, say, a Kleinian or Adlerian or Freudian approach that did not sit well with their supervisors. 

So there are dangers to be avoided, but avoiding them is far from an insurmountable problem. This returns me to my original question, phrased in the following words in the introduction to a very absorbing, richly researched, and important book on an unjustly neglected topic: Jesse D. Geller, John C. Norcross, and David E. Orlinsky, The Psychotherapist’s Own Psychotherapy : Patient and Clinician Perspectives (Oxford University Press, 2005). Here in their introduction these authors ask how and why is it that "in most European countries, a requisite number of hours of personal therapy is obligatory in order to become accredited or licensed as a psychotherapist" but "in the United States, by contrast, only analytic training institutes and a few graduate programs require a course of personal therapy" (p.5)?

Much of the rest of this book--a collection of essays from people in many countries and operating from a variety of traditions--seeks to begin to look at the frequency of, resistance to, and unique aspects uncovered in, the psychotherapy undertaken by those who are themselves therapists of some sort, noting that "many important questions about the psychotherapy of psychotherapists have not been answered or even asked by empirical investigators" (7). 

I was especially interested in a chapter by the late Harry Guntrip on being in analysis with Fairbairn and Winnicott, two of the most important figures in the British object-relations school that I have read the most about and for whom I have enormous respect. For Guntrip, the trauma of losing a brother at 3 was "softened up" by his 2 analyses but not solved: that happened after. In this, he seems a perfect illustration of something Adam Phillips said when he noted that "The cure can begin only after the treatment has ended." One can certainly debate that, but I have found it very true in my own life. 

By this I think we must include the realization not only that the analysis itself helped directly, but it also gave one the skills to carry on a regular self-analysis and create what Fred Busch called a "psychoanalytic mind."

Guntrip, Fairbairn, and Winnicott--and more recently Phillips--remain hugely important and valuable to me in very large part because they illustrate how valuable a "psychoanalytic mind" is to avoiding the dangers of rigid ideological thinking, including those too attached to one theoretical orientation! As Guntrip puts it, theory can be "a useful servant but a bad master, liable to produce orthodox defenders of every variety of the faith" (63). 

So this book varies across theoretical persuasions, but is able to draw some generalizations, noting, e.g., that "therapists enter personal treatment an average of two to three times during their careers—and probably for and during developmentally propitious crises." What is curious to me is the further reporting that even as therapists enter their own therapy, with, presumably, some self-awareness into the dynamics of resistance that they themselves see in their own patients, they cannot resist these dynamics when they are the patient: "Directly and indirectly, all of the therapist-patients in this book reported that no matter how intellectually prepared they were to collaborate, they could not 'resist resisting'" (6). 

That resistance may keep some from entering therapy, which I would regard as a great pity. More than that, I would have to wonder: how much (to speak in a Kohutian way) of a usable self do you have available for your patients whom you hope to treat in therapy? If you are one of those blessedly free but vanishingly rare people with enormous reserves of the self available, and few to no traumatic memories to work through, then praise God. But for the rest of us, the answer to the question of the psychotherapist's own psychotherapy should be: "Yes, please, let us have some more!" 

Inside Paul Wachtel's Consulting Room

I've only just come across Paul Wachtel, and am slowly trying to work my way through some of his many fascinating books, starting with Inside the Session: What Really Happens in Psychotherapy, about which some thoughts:

Wachtel starts off by noting that it is of course always easier to write about therapy neatly and tidily than describe the actual messy realities on the ground. Like Nina Coltart, whom I have discussed on here in detail, he also notes that a therapist is mostly uncertain most of the time. If you're overly confident you don't know what you're doing he says quite bluntly. 

Wachtel is quite open in this book about his repeated desire to learn from and integrate practices from the diverse traditions of CBT, experiential, systems, and psychodynamics. One concrete way he does this is to look closely at the patient's behavior in daily life: feedback loops and vicious cycles. This unites CBT and psychodynamic approaches: the thought-action cycle. Early experiences, which psychodynamic approaches focus on, are often reinforced by daily behavior today. 

He begins this attempted integration by focusing on what he regards as the central role across all these traditions of anxiety, which Freud after 1926 revised his project to say was the cornerstone, even more than repression. For Freud discovering and unlocking repression seemed to be key as one who saw himself as an archaeologist. 

The typical idea, Wachtel says, that repressed material is not just "forgotten but can be retrieved later," is no longer believed by just about anybody. Rather repressed material can be discovered in disguised forms. 

The therapeutic task is not just unmasking repressed fears and anxiety. It must also grapple with the corrective emotional experience? In so doing, Wachtel says, psychotherapy has undergone a shift from merely unmasking fears to helping the patient bear them.

Wachtel recognizes a considerable body of evidence pointing to the central role of exposure in helping with this task. CBT does this all the time, but Wachtel says it happens in different ways in psychodynamic treatment as well. In the former it is not just a matter of treating immediate thoughts and behavior, and regarding that as sufficient; in the latter it is not just a matter of insight into fears and anxieties, and treating insight as sufficient. Integrated therapy needs and must seek after both. 

In both cases, what is, he says, not often remarked but nonetheless very powerful, is the role of kindness. Wachtel: "the history of psychoanalysis is replete with comments about the importance of kindness, caring, and the offering of the analyst’s more benign vision of what is possible for the patient as a substitute for the patient’s harsh superego" (p.14). This book challenges directly the idea that a clinician should be neutral, aloof, non-gratifying of patient's desires. Instead, "a warmly supportive stance toward the patient is the best facilitator of his capacity to explore previously warded-off thoughts, feelings, and wishes" (19).

This leads Wachtel to recognize that it is insufficient for an analyst or analytic therapist merely to proffer insight, or to insist of facing fears, without providing that kindness out of which the therapist comes to recognize that resistance is not irrational opposition to the therapist, but instead reflects the fact that the patient is terrified. So therapy must give the pt. space and safety to begin reappropriating cut-off parts of his psyche.

The task of the therapist here is to maintain a necessary balance, that is to "root the therapeutic effort in the dialectic between accepting the patient’s experience of the world and helping him to change those features of his assumptive world that are contributing to his pain." One must proceed with a careful hand here, for, as Wachtel continues, "in good part, change is reached by not trying to change the patient, or, more accurately I think, by both trying and not trying at the same time" (p.18). Only after feeling understood can a pt. begin to think about change.

Though written nearly a decade ago before "resiliency" became the buzzword it increasingly is today, Wachtel insists in this book that successful therapeutic change requires looking at positive cycles too. Patient and therapist need to focus on the patient's strengths as key to therapy--not just focusing on pathology.

Wachtel here very much echoes the great Adam Phillips in arguing that "When successful, psychotherapy helps the patient to retell his life story, to provide a different frame and give a different moral to the story. Hence, it enables him to give different meaning to events and experiences." This is a point that Phillips has often made.

Finally, Wachtel notes that a good therapeutic alliance and working relationship can have positive spillover effects in other areas outside the consulting room. 

Jeffrey Kottler on Being a Therapist

This book, On Being a Therapist, is now in its fifth edition (Oxford University Press, 2017). As the author, Jeffrey Kottler, notes in the introduction, it could scarcely have been imagined in the mid-1980s, when this book was first published, how much would change today in the field of psychotherapy--not just advances in techniques, but in psychopharmacology, the insurance industry, and much else besides. Nevertheless, the author has sought to keep the book updated in light of new developments while aiming it at the widest audience of clinicians from all backgrounds--social work, psychology, counselling, psychiatry. He says it is especially aimed at students in all those disciplines who get into one of those professions without always fully realizing the personal consequences, with which he begins the book in Ch.1: The Therapist's Journey.

In this chapter the author sketches out the lofty potential of the therapeutic vocation: the ability to make a change in the lives of others unlike anything else, leading potentially to "spiritual transcendence" (p.1).

The ability to effect such change depends in good measure on the therapist's personality. Here Kottler echoes something much remarked upon in many other publications: above and beyond theoretical orientation and even certain techniques, the personality, and from it the therapeutic alliance, are fundamental, leading to change not just for patients but also therapists themselves. Kottler notes that therapy can produce an "altered state of consciousness" in both therapist and patient. This is especially so if the alignment is right and healthy, when there can be a kind of "second sight" at work.

Much like Nina Coltart (whom he does not quote or seem to have read), Kottler speaks of the importance of faith in the process, faith in the therapist, as being key factors in helping motivate people to seek and find change. Beyond that, Kottler suggests we go too far in thinking we can always and everywhere pinpoint the cause of change, even after lengthy in-depth study.  Therapists have to have "learned to love this sort of ambiguity and complexity" or else probably find another career (p.5). A little later Kottler says that "I have never really trusted anyone who claims to understand how therapy works. I think it is far too complex" (14).

That complexity and ambiguity can open the door to self-understanding and experimentation by the therapist, who also functions as a model: if the therapist models courage, it may aid the patient in being courageous enough to risk and experiment with change in his or her own life.

Ch.2: Struggles for Power and Influence contains some important reflections on serious issues.

Kottler begins by noting something that goes back at least to Freud: resistance. Therapists want to encourage change, but patients will not only resist that, but turn the tables, fighting to change not themselves but the therapist. They will want the therapist to take their side, to adopt their view, to love them more, to reduce and belittle the therapist and thus attempt to work out their own sadomasochistic transferences (a process which, as several others--e.g., Robert Stoller--have recognized, is often a reflection of early trauma).

Kottler notes a change here that has occurred in the last several decades: the decline of the therapist as all-knowing, largely aloof guru or expert. Thankfully that is a model and an approach largely in disfavor today. Instead patients increasingly see therapists as people with specialized training and insight whose job is to help patients discover what it is they want and need, and try to help them attain that at least in part. Kottler uses the metaphor of a "coach" here to try to capture something of this shift. He also speaks of the therapist as "model" of some beliefs, behaviors, and practices that the patient may very much want to try out and eventually adopt.

What is it that therapists should model? Here Kottler notes numerous important and distinguishing characteristics of therapists, including their
  • tolerance
  • sincerity
  • serenity
  • tranquility
  • self-assurance 
  • self-disciplined regularity that can nonetheless be spontaneous
He also notes in this chapter that the "energy" of the therapist can be hugely helpful and influential, not just as a model for long-term change, but in the immediacy of the here-and-now of the consulting room. The containing therapist, who offers a strong "holding environment," as Winnicott famously called it, can have a profound effect on disturbed and distressed patients.

A few other random things that stuck out to me in this book: In his fifth chapter, Kottler notes how much of "continuing education" is a scam, designed to offer a continuing source of cash and credentialing power to various groups, but very often only the most superficial "education" imaginable. I've heard this from other therapists, and from perusing some prominent websites, seen it up close.

His reflections on seduction in the transference is especially useful. Noting that patients may be seductive for reasons other than the straightforwardly or explicitly sexual, he notes that regardless of motives, there are no easy ways to deal with this problem. He further notes this can be a desire to establish a deep emotional relationship rather than a physical one, and that this obtains even when patient and therapist are of the same sex.

Kottler is also helpful on dealing with difficult patients, offering several insights, starting with the fact that it is important to recognize that at least some of the time it may not be them, but you: are you too impatient to change them, too resentful of a perceived loss of control in the relationship? Maybe they are "difficult" and resentful and resistant because the relationship is misaligned. As my supervisor often says, you need in these moments to check the goals of therapy because chances are good the "resistance" here is due to a misalignment of goals--e.g., the therapist wants to go farther, or faster, or further into an area than the patient does or can currently handle.

In this light, Kottler also offers advice I've seen in others: resistance is a powerful message. Try to understand and interpret it. What is it protecting? What was its function?

Perhaps more important, and certainly more difficult, is to ask yourself whether "it could be said that much of client resistance results, in part, from some blocking that occurs in the therapist" (p.208). This, as I've also learned from Otto Kernberg and Nina Coltart, is where mining the counter-transference is crucial for knowledge about blockages in the therapist as well, of course, as--possibly--the patient.

But look, moreover, at cultural background to see if some of the struggles can be located here. Regardless of origin or cause, the therapist needs to remain flexible, patient, compassionate, and available to help people change at their own pace when they are ready, recognizing that some people may never get there or may be incurable. Have the humility to admit this, and also to admit that sometimes the most difficult patients can also be the greatest teachers.

Finally, have not only humility, but plenty of self-compassion, Kottler reiterates several times. This is good advice I've seen in others, including Adam Phillips, about whom much more another time.

How to Survive as a Therapist or Singing the Praises of Nina Coltart (II)

I have previously, and at some length, noted what I have learned from the delightful Nina Coltart.

Continuing on from there, let us turn now to her third and final book, The Baby and the Bathwater, published in 1996, a year before Coltart's death.

The book opens with a preface from the Anglo-American psychoanalyst Christopher Bollas, whose many books I commend to your attention and hope to reflect on later. Bollas notes that Coltart has here offered us "luminous autumnal visions of her life." If, he says, this is indeed her last book (as Coltart said it would be), then Bollas thinks she has saved the best for last.

Her first chapter opens with a case-study of a patient, a Welsh man, who was one of her first patients in the 1960s, from whom, she says, she may have learned more than anyone else. One important lesson was to find in certain sadomasochistic practices of this patient a "reparative wish" to overcome early childhood trauma, a phenomenon which has been much remarked on by other clinicians, including Robert Stoller and Adam Phillips.

In her second chapter, "Why Am I Here?" she returns to a theme we have seen in the past: that of the therapist's vocation, which, in the next chapter, she speaks of as a vocation to "this rather cloistered life," an image I find tremendously appealing.

She notes that a vocation has five features:
  • giftedness
  • belief in the power of the unconscious
  • strength of purpose
  • reparativeness
  • curiosity
Of these, she suggests the reparative drive is the one that most distinguishes a therapeutic calling while also leading into the countertransference. 

To the above list she later in the chapter adds "the capacity to love" one's patients, which need not consist always in positive feelings. Indeed, she recognizes one can love without always liking. In this, she puts me in mind of a more "medieval" or scholastic definition of love that consists in willing (perhaps today we might say "desiring") the good of the other.

She also notes in this chapter--without using the phrase, which does not seem to have caught on until after Coltart wrote--the importance of what today is very frequently described as "self-care." Coltart here speaks with characteristic bluntness: "take it seriously when I say that you need to attend with real care to rest, relaxation, and refreshment, wherever you personally find it. Don't let your devotion to the job become too contaminated by superego elements and certainly don't let guilt percolate into any of your forms of relaxation and rest" (39). Later on, in her penultimate chapter, "Endings," she adds to this by quoting an unnamed colleague: "Try not to worry about your patients and certainly don't ever take worry home with you overnight. Be concerned for your patients always--you will find that with true concern you can leave them behind when you aren't with them" (142-43). 

She ends this chapter by noting that "We have the most interesting job in the world."  

Skipping to her fourth chapter, "Handling the Transference," Coltart stresses once more the importance of being "humble and self-effacing" and perhaps this is nowhere more important than in not "pushing the river" as my supervisor, Dr Carl Jylland-Halverson, memorably phrases it. For Coltart, she says pushing a patient to a recognition before they are ready, before they themselves have almost grasped and voiced it directly, will almost always backfire. Here she quotes the old line "A man convinced against his will/Retains his old conviction still."

Coltart remained convinced, here and elsewhere, of the importance of returning again and again to Freud's early technical papers (esp. those between 1910 and 1915), and here notes how much Freud anticipated, correctly, the great emphasis placed today on establishing a good "therapeutic alliance." She also notes how he changed his mind (which far too few people seem to realize or credit him with) on a number of things, and was not nearly the dogmatician in everything he is sometimes portrayed as.

In her final chapter, which gives its name to the title of the book, she throws out a few provocative final ideas without much developing them. And she reflects on the importance of periodic throwing out of the "bathwater" of certain ideas--or, conversely, the retention of them, as the case may be. The point is to scrutinize what we have learned to see if it is still effective and valuable, and if not then to get rid of it rather than engage in what I might call a form of ideological hording or theoretical anal-retentiveness.

She confesses she's puzzled by people who remember their analysis in great detail, noting with evident relief that "many, however, do not, which is consoling."

One idea she goes after with especial bluntness, recognizing it may be controversial: that of analytic therapy as not providing a "corrective emotional experience." She notes its provenance in the 1940s in people like Alexander and French (and, I would add, later figures such as Sullivan and Yalom), but says that too many analysts poured cold water on the idea. Coltart's having none of it, insisting that of course analysis and analytic therapy does provide a corrective emotional experience, and there's no need to hide behind analytic neutrality or abstinence in denying this. In fact, ending this book by returning to her previous book, as I noted, Coltart says that therapy should not just supply a "corrective emotional experience" but it should also quite unapologetically give both therapist and patient an experience of enjoyment. 

With that, we come to the end of Coltart's third and final book, and the end of her life. In a future post, we hope to look at the lovely Festschrift that was published posthumously: Her Hour Come Round at Last: A Garland for Nina Coltart.