Posts

Showing posts with the label sexual boundaries

Desire: An Enigma Wrapped In Riddles Inside Mystery

Introduction:

I learn such things on Twitter. 

I forget to whom exactly to give credit for introducing me to Galit Atlas and her book, The Enigma of Desire: Sex, Longing, and Belonging in Psychoanalysis (Routledge, 2016). It may well have first been Adam Rodriguez, but I know it was even more forcefully Taylor Zimmerman, whom I met with great delight in Indianapolis in April at the celebrated day with Jonathan Shedler. Over the coffee hour and in subsequent correspondence, Taylor strongly encouraged me to read Atlas, so I am grateful to him as to Adam. 

Atlas is the third person in an ongoing series of clinicians in whom I am finding much wisdom with regard to erotic dynamics in psychotherapy, especially in the transference and countertransference. The first of these was, and is, Andrea Celenza, about whom I first wrote here, and more recently here. 

She and Glen Gabbard are arguably the two leading scholar-clinicians writing on sexualized boundary violations in professional contexts, including clinical and clerical contexts. Given the power of their writings, and the fact these topics are almost universally ignored in all training programs, and even by licensed professionals, I am at the point now where I just flatly tell anyone who asks, and even more who don't, that they should buy all of Gabbard's books and all of Celenza's and read them. Were I in charge of training programs in this country for future clinicians of all sorts, I would absolutely make these two authors mandatory reading. 

Into this group I now can bring Galit Atlas, who writes in a different style and with a different focus than Gabbard and Celenza, but with them is still broadly in the field--hitherto often terribly overlooked or denied--of erotic dynamics in treatment. Her book, The Enigma of Desire, puts me in mind of another recent treatment by another psychoanalyst, Carlos Dominguez-Morano (whose utterly irreplaceable Belief After Freud should also be required reading, not least by Christians still talking bollocks about Freud), The Myth of Desire: Sexuality, Love, and the Self, which I have to go back and re-read. 

Right, down to business. 

Atlas on Maternal Erotics:

Atlas begins punchily enough in her introduction by arguing that "In treatment, adopting the role of a nurturing mother can function as the therapist's way to avoid the erotic material that emerges between her and the patient." This I take to be just another version of the important warning (echoed by Shedler, Maroda, McWilliams, and many others) that being too much of a "container" (Bion) or providing little more than a "holding environment" (Winnicott) will mean you ultimately fail your patient who is there because something is wrong and something needs to be changed, not merely contained. 

A second related warning follows from this later in the book (p.80): "our patients' traumatized self-states may collude with our own in order to protect the tender parts of the self, the other, and the treatment from damage by the aggressive parts." (This, of course, is reason #23689 for the psychotherapist to have had his or her own in-depth and intensive long-term psychotherapy, and to engage in regular supervision and consultation.)

Also early in her book Atlas makes plain her own debts to what she calls Kleinian mothers, who have led her to be able "to trust the mind to lead us to the most unknown truths and to believe that the ability to tolerate those tensions allows us to live and to love." She also mentions her debts to Laplanche and Kristeva, and Jessica Benjamin, especially this: "I do not believe we can definitely know what belongs to us and what belongs to our patients." 

This point, of course, puts one in mind of Thomas Ogden's celebrated notion of the analytic third, and of the inability, as he has also recognized, to know where the patient's experience ends and the clinician's begins. 

The Erotics of Writing:

There is a sensuous quality to Atlas's writing itself, not least in her case studies, which are presented here in ways that are less stilted and bloodless than one so often finds. That is to say, there is still a warm pulse in the people she writes about. 

Moreover, and more interesting for me who has long loved to write and cared deeply about the felicities and rewards of style, and who has often felt a flush of excitement in the exchange of ideas, she openly acknowledges that "While writing, I found myself...swinging from feeling overaroused and exposed to using ideas as a way to distance, process, and regulate" (p.30). Lest we miss the point, a bit later she quotes a famous 1989 paper of Ronald Britton in which he recounts a patient demanding: "'Stop that fucking thinking'!" From this Atlas deduces that "thinking is a form of the therapist's internal intercourse" (p.32). Just so! 

I can relate to that outside the consulting room, but also in, which she captures with equal candor: "I notice the movement between moments of sexual stimulation and arousal to use of theory....I believe we often experience the same movement as analysts trying to regulate ourselves and our patients when the erotic pervades the analytic space" (p.30). Guilty as charged! (If I find myself becoming very theoretical, or subjecting the patient to a lecture, than I know my intellectualized defenses have led to such an enactment, and, following Fonagy's counsel, I need to rewind the session back to the point where I was able to mentalize before the defenses were, uh, aroused.)

The Enigmatic and the Pragmatic:

The unique contribution that Atlas make, so far as I can see at this point, is her stress on what she calls Enigmatic and Pragmatic knowing. Much more could be said about this, but I don't want to give all of the book away, so suffice it for me to say that the enigmatic and pragmatic are tied to her dual understanding of the origins of, changes in, and different desires manifested in sexuality: "the erotic comes into existence when the sexuality that at the start was based exclusively on nourishment and satisfaction of hunger moves away from the functional and toward play" (p.41). 

Do not, she warns later, be too enchanted (as some of us who love Winnicott are inclined to be) by notions of play, for these, too, can be used to displace certain important things: "playfullness can be a seductive way to express erotic and aggressive contents...but it's important to note that it can also serve to obstruct erotic transference and countertransference" (p.81). Yes it can, as I've noticed in some sessions after the fact, and not without some chagrin! 

Sexual Longing and Erotic Manifestations and Their Dangers:

Her mention of the erotic obstructing transference material takes us back onto more familiar ground, also covered by Gabbard and Celenza, and then by David Mann, whose two books on the topic I began last weekend, and about which I will have a very great deal to say later (O lucky reader!). 

Rightly does Atlas note early in the book that "sometimes we underestimate how dangerous it feels to be part of a dyad." I try to remind myself of that at least a few times a week, and (for some reason) it always happens at the last turn of the corridor immediately before bringing a patient into my consulting room. In those seconds as I usher them in, I cast my mind back to the first time I ever met with a psychotherapist (a pastoral counselor as I recall) in my teen years (to discuss sexual matters, too!), and how anxious I felt: I try to get a feel for whether this person with me is also a bit anxious, which is an entirely understandable feeling for, as Atlas continues a bit later, "being a patient is a dangerous position" for the patient may feel "he is forced back into the powerless position of being a child to a seductive mother who penetrates and excites him, feeds him but also controls his food and will certainly abandon him, leaving him overexcited, humiliated, and alone" (p.37). 

Strong stuff! No wonder people on Twitter lose their bloody minds when you speak such thoughts aloud; no wonder my undergrads had a collective meltdown at the mention of any hint of anything remotely "erotic" in the therapeutic relationship; no wonder even licensed professionals shy away from these discussions at best, and at worst become amusingly and revealingly hyper-defended. 

Why would anyone submit to this humiliating penetration and abandonment? Later she notes some of its rewards: "Allowing yourself to be penetrated means embracing a more fluid structure that is based on unsolidified boundaries....This is not exclusively a feminine process" (p.69). Indeed not. 

Precisely my attraction to psychoanalytic thinking, starting with Freud, more than three decades ago now was because it seemed to be quite at home with the idea of the fluidity, the complexity, the ambiguity and ambivalence--the sheer messiness--of human sexuality. I have always been highly suspicious of anyone who wants to put it into neat boxes, or map it out on a linear continuum or Kinsey scale. None of us is ever "straight." 

Before going further, she reminds us that for many of us, we had (referring to Kohut) no "mirroring" of the erotic and sexual growing up: "sexual feelings are unique in that caregivers systematically ignore them and they are therefore unmirrored" (p.115). This will and will not show up in a variety of ways in life, and in therapy. 

For some this lack of mirroring can leave the terror of such feelings in place, and that is where you must begin in therapy: "are there ways to listen for, and to, the unique accents of the language of sex." And if those accents are ones of fear, then, nodding towards Bion, Atlas says that an early task of the second mind in the room is to help the first mind bear to think about those fearful desires and terrifying thoughts.

As you think about them, some of the difficulty of such feelings comes from the fact that "sexual longing presupposes a sense of loss and a hope of refinding." 

That refinding is not a straightforward path from infantile attachment to adult sexual longings. It is often much more complicated than that, and thus the clinician needs to proceed with due caution: "the secret psychoanalytic touch is always about tolerating the erotic in the room while not adding to the stimulus." 

Earlier, she notes that we can and probably should do more than that: "we try to hold the unknown darkness with them, tolerate the 'too muchness' of excitement, joy, horror, and shame." Later she will speak of the "suffering of pleasure, of the excess that the body and the mind cannot contain," to which some might give the name "lust" while others (here Melanie Klein) prefer to speak of "human yearning for an 'unattainable perfect internal state'." 

Enactments Made and Redeemed:

Atlas is making what seems to me a very significant advance on how we think about therapeutic enactments. That word is almost universally taken as a sign of danger and enactments seem almost always to be treated sternly. This mirrors, it seems to me, the early Freud and his unidimensional warnings about the dangers of transference and countertransference especially. Only after 1950 did we start to get some limited reflection on what positive things countertransference might contain, and only much later--that is, within the relational movement of which Atlas is a significant part--do we start to see people recognize that countertransference can often be a positive good and contain much valuable information.

Similarly, Atlas is, in the last section of the last chapter of her book, opening up new territory by arguing that enactments are not just "a return of past dissociated memories but rather as the threshold for the introduction of emergent ways of being, of an opening toward new relational possibilities" (p.150). Enactments thus "work toward the future."

They do more than that, as becomes clear in her attempted definition: "enactments may well be a central means by which patients and analysts enter into each other's inner world and discover themselves as participants within each other's psychic life" (p.150). This does not guarantee, of course, that all enactments will always have a positive outcome, but it does begin to help them lose some of their fear, just as we have overcome fear from a century ago of countertransference as a sign of an insufficiently analyzed analyst. 

A concluding word that reminds us of how demanding our vocation as psychotherapists is, for we "must straddle a paradox, always skeptical, questioning, seeking hidden meanings, searching for unconscious dynamics at play, the trailing edge, a hermeneutics of suspicion--while also, paradoxically, trusting unconscious process and surrendering to the continuous flow of the enactive dimension of analysis, relying on a hermeneutics of faith" (here referencing Ricoeur).

On Sexualized Defenses, Transferences, and Counter-Transferences

Though I can remember almost none of my undergraduate professors at the University of Ottawa from the early 1990s, I have never forgotten Dr Arthur Blank, for both salutary and unsavory reasons. The salutary: I got to write a research paper in his Family Psychology class on what happens to families (such as mine) with a child who is chronically ill and then dies, and it was a profoundly revealing and helpful experience which earned me an A (not a grade I was anywhere near in my psychometrics or neurobiology classes that semester!), and gave me new and more sympathetic insights into what my parents faced and the choices they made to concentrate on my sister in the last six years of her life to the inevitable and unavoidable neglect of me and my younger sisters for most of our late childhood and nearly entire adolescence. 

The unsavory: a few months after class ended, he was in the papers on a regular basis being sued by former patients whom he had sexually abused in his private practice, including a woman who went into therapy with him to deal with having been sexually abused while growing up. He would be struck off the register of psychologists in Ontario and have to pay hundreds of thousands in damages to his ex-patients. I read the newspaper accounts with horror that a man could do such a thing to vulnerable patients. 

This coincided with living with a roommate, whom I knew slightly from my church (which very much encouraged his moving in), who had all kinds of issues with boundaries; we ended up having to ask him to leave. And it also coincided a few months later with my starting analysis and the great pains my analyst took to coax me onto the couch, which I was more than a little frightened of for the vulnerable position it places one in. ("What's she thinking back there watching me? What if she reaches around and touches me before I can see what she's up to and leap out of the way?")

Boundaries, then, have long been prominent in my mind. A few weeks back, I had occasion to read Glen Gabbard, "Lessons to be Learned from the Study of Sexual Boundary Violations" last week (American Journal of Psychotherapy 50, Summer 1996: pp.311-322). I posted insights from that on Twitter. He offers clear and concrete guidelines for avoiding boundary violations based on his work with more than 100 such cases. 

As important as his work in this essay is, he does not reflect on what might be useful in erotic transferences and counter-transferences and how to handle them in a profitable way that does not lead to disastrous outcomes. That crucial task falls to Andrea Celenza, Erotic Revelations: Clinical Applications and Perverse Scenarios (Routledge, 2014), who breaks the ice on these discussions (for me at least). As she notes, much of the clinical literature and likely almost all supervisory contexts avoid the topic because of the understandable fear and even shame such things evoke. 

I was not familiar with her work until Adam Rodriguez on Twitter mentioned how important her work is, and how she should be required reading in training programs. Having taken at least one lesson from her already, and used it in my own supervision, I would agree: she offers insights that begin a long overdue discussion, and we should be introducing that discussion to our students and supervisees. 

What do I mean by that? My take-away from her many insights is that there is a necessary difference between erotic attraction and sexual enactment, and that to feel and discuss the former without shame is not to necessarily risk the latter. Indeed, to put the point more strongly: perhaps the extent to which we feel more free to discuss erotic elements in the transference and counter-transference we may deprive them of the power of secrecy which so often masks and precedes boundary violations. Reading her book has in fact moved me along into feeling more comfortable discussing these things with my own supervisor, who has himself published on problems of sexual boundaries with certain populations, and discusses these with grace and good humour (not unlike Celenza's own supervisor as recounted in an hilarious anecdote on p. 69). 

The other crucial insight she offers is that sexual desire between patient and psychotherapist is always complex and complicated. Though Celenza is not so blunt on this point, I take her to be reminding therapists that if you think your patient really wants to just have sex with you in some straightforward manner, then you are deluded and have indulged in a self-serving and grossly reductionistic attempt to focus on only one thing: your desire. In this monomaniacal pursuit, you not only take your eye off the patient and his or her welfare, but you also fail to recognize that the patient's putative desire for you is highly ambivalent and complicated by many factors, and most certainly does not mean what you want it to. 

She puts it more elegantly and less compactly throughout the book, noting, first, that "being multiple selves is the human condition, and being multiple others to our patients is the analytic condition" (p.62). This multiplicity of self-states comes up several times in the book, and puts me in mind of a wonderful essay by Phillip Bromberg, "Standing in the Spaces," that I read recently and profitably. 

She continues in this vein, arguing, second, that "the gender that the analyst is...is not necessarily the only gender the analyst can be in the erotic transference" (ibid). I found this very revealing, opening up a new way of trying to understand same-sex erotic transference which baffled me in one particular case.

So the patient--whether male or female--could be responding erotically to us in a more maternal or masculine, or paternal or feminine role, or mixtures thereof; they could be responding from a younger and more childish part of the self, or (in our counter-transference) we to them from such multiple and entangled and ambiguous self-states of our own. Thus we see that the erotic response of patient to analyst, and therapist to patient, is not at all clear or straightforward, and responding as though it is will always invite disaster. (Celenza notes in an offhand passage something that Gabbard goes into in more detail: sexualized boundary crossings often happen when the therapist is engaged in "defensive efforts to manage our self-neglect" [p.67, with a reference to her 2007 book on the topic].)

Third, she states a little later that "the wish to know the analyst sexually is invariably complicated and usually highly conflicted. And if it is not, it should be, given the inherent power imbalances" in the therapeutic relationship (p.79). This theme of power imbalance is one she threads throughout much of the book, noting that it is inevitable no matter how much some misguided efforts might be made to flatten things and to insist patient and clinician meet on equal terms. We do not, and never will. 

I remember almost nothing else from one of my first supervisors, but he made damn sure to pound into my head one crucial point: We are not and never will be friends with our patients. A fortiori, we are never going to be lovers, either. As Adam Phillips says in one of his many wonderful books, psychoanalysis welcomes exploration of any and all topics no matter how emotionally and erotically laden and we can do this only because we agree never to have sex with each other.

On the question of sexual desires and their conflicts, I think the crucial passage in the entire book is this:

What do our patients want? They say they want our love, or more pointedly, to have sex--but do they really want that? We are many things to our patients simultaneously and equally important: analyst, woman, person, mother, father, sibling, and child....At any one time a plea for love or sex is a plea from within only one of those dimensions....The man may want a kiss, but the child does not. 

From this she follows up even more directly, insisting that "our patients do not really want us to gratify their erotic wishes, despite their vociferous protests to the contrary. But they do not want us to simply maintain our professional role either" (p.68-69). 

How, then, ought we to handle such things if it seems we are caught on the horns of a most serious dilemma? I confess I was gratified to read of her approach, which I stumbled upon myself before I had heard of this book. Celenza notes that if we cannot indulge patient desires, nor shut them down in a brutally "professional" way (for both responses harm patients in different ways), what is needed of us? Patients need us to respond to them as human beings, and so she said that sometimes a response like "I would if I could!" or "In another time or place" are just the sorts of responses "we need to convey to our patients" (p.69). (Quoted in this way, it may sound like Celenza is a bit flippant about such matters, but the force of her cogent book is quite to the contrary: she has clearly thought about such matters in depth and has hard-won wisdom abundantly displayed throughout the book.) 

I do not want to suggest this book is only devoted to these issues. Its other riches include good discussions in ch.1 especially on overly restrictive ideas of gender and on the uses of sexuality as a defense mechanism. Ironically, sexualized defenses and behaviors can often be used to stave off intimacy--a theme she devotes the entire second part of the book to in her focus on sadomasochistic and perverse habits and enactments. 

That final section, on sadomasochism, explicitly draws on a book I have half-finished right now: Robert Stoller's Perversion: The Erotic Form of Hatred. Celenza picks up where Stoller (whose work was published in 1975 but still has valuable insights for me at least in clinical work with sex offenders) leaves off and gives us a nuanced and balanced assessment before concluding that in her view sadomasochistic enactments are problematic insofar as they may be attempts to destroy any "tolerance of dependency, vulnerability, and self-revelation" (p.114) and may participate in "dehumanization of the other" (p.109). She notes that too often sadomasochistic habits may exist as a "closed feedback loop in which repetition and sameness is substituted for creativity and growth" (p.100). She gives an encouraging case study of one such patient who was finally able, after intensive analysis, to move into a much freer and more loving relationship with a woman who became his wife.