Posts

Showing posts with the label John Bowlby

David Wallin on Attachment in Psychotherapy

This book, Attachment in Psychotherapy, has something of a legendary status in the field it seems to me, so it was on my long-term list of things I knew I must read at some point. But one of the things I learned from Nina Coltart is that clinical work has a way, largely unconsciously, of bumping things up your priority list depending on whom you are treating at any given moment. So with several new cases presenting with what seems to me dismissive and avoidant attachment histories that immediately seemed a threat to treatment even beginning, never mind proceeding successfully, I felt I had to do more work in both attachment and mentalization. So with gratitude and relief I picked up David Wallin's Attachment in Psychotherapy. 

The book begins with the ultimate hook to scholar-clinicians such as I: "How does psychotherapy enable people to change" (p.xi)? Whose blood is immediately not set aracing by such a crucial and intriguing question? 

He immediately posits that an answer to such a question almost certainly has something to do with giving a relational connection and context not unlike that of primary attachment figures in early life, here mentioning to me the surprising claim that Bowlby, famous for his attachment theory, was much more of a clinician than academic, seeing a considerable number of patients who seem to have occupied more time than I ever realized.  

Much of attachment begins at the most primitive, per-verbal levels, and Wallin here calls to mind Christopher Bollas and his notion of the unthought known. This is especially true for disavowed or dissociated experience, which may well end up, Wallin says, being enacted, embodied, or evoked in others. The therapist skilled in mentalization, Wallin says--here tying his own work to that of Fonagy (given his own chapter--#4) which I have also found, and continue to find, so very helpful--will help the patient see these three patterns and begin to reflect on and own them. The therapist who exhibits and encourages such mentalization will likely have a "contagious quality," helping the patient's capacities to expand and grow outside the consulting room.

Wallin also brings in the work of metacognition, which bears a good deal of similarity to mentalization, though the former term was primarily developed in the US while the latter in the UK. In the US Paul Lysaker is most associated with the term in my mind, and his work on metacognition in psychotic disorders informs my own clinical work and has proven very helpful. 

Ch.2, The Foundations of Attachment Theory, covers not just John Bowlby but also Mary Ainsworth's equally important pioneering work here. The gist of this is to show that "an abundance of follow-up studies has tended to show that the attachment patterns of infancy have long-term effects" (p.23). Another number of studies suggest that parents replicate with their infants and children their own attachment patterns and struggles.

Ch.3 focuses directly on Ainsworth, noting that "without a functioning capacity for metacognition, we may for the moment find ourselves in a particular state of mind; lacking such a capacity, it's as if we simply are that state of mind" (p.40). Helping my patients appreciate this has in several cases proven a turning point in treatment. They had hitherto felt helpless in certain affective states, as though controlled by them: Fonagy calls this "embeddeness." But being able to reflect on them, to sit with and observe them as they come and go, has been very helpful. 

As we move into ch.6 of Wallin's book, he makes a useful caveat that perhaps cannot be stated enough: "the fact is that their [patients'] complexity can never be adequately captured by a single descriptor--secure, dismissing, preoccuped, or unresolved" (p.96). Do not, in other words--as I constantly tell my students--expect to see people show up in your consulting room straight out of central casting, with clear, precise, unambiguous clinical presentation allowing you easily and immediately to tick some theoretical or diagnostic box--avoidant! bipolar! OCD! Rare are such patients. 

Ch.8 focuses explicitly on Bollas and the unthought known, emphasizing that patients who cannot put certain things into words will show us by their actions, and that enactments in therapy will also be crucial forms of communication. Here and in many other places in the book, Wallin stresses that with patients whose ability to communicate their struggles in words is limited, "we must tune in to our own subjective experience" (p.129). Such experience includes all of us: Wallin cautions that the "taking cure" must not be limited to "talking heads," but include the whole body. 

Resuming themes of mentalization, Wallin goes on to state quite clearly that "helping patients change their stance toward their own subjective experience depends, in part, on our explicit mentalizing." Lest some think this insufficient--where's the homework? work-sheets? skills building? breathing exercises?--he insists a little further down the same page that "rather than any particular understanding, it is the experience in which the patient feels understood--and inspired to understand herself--that is ultimately most therapeutic" (p.157). 

He resumes this theme later in the book, noting that "for patients who are unresolved the therapeutic relationship is the therapy" (p.244) and such therapy provides an "incremental achievement of a sense of safety in relation to the therapist," and to that extent may heal previously traumatic relationships. Put in classical terminology, psychotherapy that provides "the patient with a secure base" is offering him or her "a corrective relational experience that may be healing in its own right" (p.257).  

Ch.10 brings in the work of Phillip Bromberg, to whom I was recently introduced. His idea of multiple self-states, and of change being something more than a static end-point at which we arrive and stay, has been extremely illuminating for me. Wallin draws on him in this chapter as well as Bion's notion of helping the patient contain "disowned thoughts, feelings, and desires" which can be reintegrated once they have been held in mind by the psychotherapist (p.183). 

Wallin goes on to argue something that I have recently been learning (not without struggle!) from the new book of Karen Maroda (and before her from Nina Coltart and others): the need sometimes less for containment (pace Bion) and more for confrontation and challenge. As Wallin puts it simply, "it must be understood that our patients at times need confrontation more than they need empathy" (p.200). He seems to suggest a little later that this is especially so with those who exibit a predominantly avoidant and dismissive attachment style, clues about which can be found in a tendency to lapse into irrelevancies and to exhibit certain things bodily. For such patients, we need to combine "empathic attunement with confrontation" so that the dismissing patient is led to see "how he gets to us" (p.212). 

We do this, of course, not via a "barrage of honesty" but in a way that the "patient can make use of." In doing so, Wallin cautions toward the end of the book (repeating a theme throughout), we communicate usefully using words, but in other ways as well. If we are not attuned to non-verbal communication, our utility to the patient is going to be limited to just that extent. Thus we must cultivate what he calls "open presence" (310) and earlier "bare attention" (the exact phrase I first learned from Nina Coltart). Such bare attention, Wallin notes at the end of the book, should be offered with in "calm, quiet" ways, quoting one of Freud's technical papers from 1912 (to which Coltart says clinicians should return regularly). 

When we are communicating via words, Wallin hints that it is better to use observation statements than questions: "Generally I prefer to simply comment on what I think I see, letting the meaning emerge from the joint exploration the comment usually elicits" (p.299). 

In the end, we do all this, he says in a neat summary of the book, because "in the new attachment relationship we aim to provide for our patients, repeated experiences of disembedding through mindfulness as well as mentalizing can establish a competing centre of organization in both the mind and brain. In this way such experiences can potentially replace the patient's insecure working models with 'earned secure' ones" (p.337). 

On Mentalizing and Attachment

I have been aware for some time of the work of Peter Fonagy in England. But it was only more recently that I discovered his American colleague Jon G. Allen. Both have written about "mentalizing" as important in therapy. The pair of them have teamed up together with Andrew Batemen to write Mentalizing in Clinical Practice (APA Books, 2008). I mined this book for some good insights, and was not disappointed. Herewith a few of them:

Mentalizing: What Is It?

In their introduction they offer several quick, simple definitions of mentalization, including:

holding mind in mind

attending to mental states in yourself and in others

understanding misunderstandings

seeing yourself from the outside while seeing others from the inside

In the concluding appendix, they return to offer another simple definition of mentalizing: "You are mentalizing when you're aware of what's going on in your mind or someone else's" (311). Examples of this might include asking yourself "Why did I do that?" or "Why did she say that hurtful thing?" 

Practical Recommendations:

These authors offer some very practical recommendations in trying to increase the capacity for mentalization in patients: take your time; don't rush this; don't get out of step with your patient. If in doubt, confirm first (the patient's thoughts/experiences) and challenge later. 

Why do this? Why is mentalizing important? They find that its lack is almost always related to an attachment failure, early abuse or trauma, or substance abuse. Restoring the ability to mentalize can be both healing in itself but also open up further depths to be explored in therapy. The whole point of therapy is to open up alternate interpretations and to insert spaces where there were none before. This extends to allowing and encouraging the pt. to mentalize the transference: to look at this relationship now and imagine what might be going on in the therapist's mind while also discussing what is going on in your mind as a patient. 

Without Memory or Desire:

These authors offer what I would characterize as some very Bionian counsel: Be very at home in not knowing, not having memory or desire. Do not be an expert, for you are not an expert in the patient's mind! 

If you are trying to be mindful of their mind, then they recommend that the therapist make contrary moves: if the patient is excessively introspective, invite them to consider how another mind might see something; if they are obsessed with how others see it, invite them to offer their own thoughts from their own mind. 

As you and they offer such thoughts, watch the adverbs! Avoid using such terms as clearly, only, obviously, just, etc. If your patient uses them, you might want to challenge them gently, especially if such adverbs precede significant minimization of major events or issues or pain. 

Ask for feedback if a conflict is brewing: What have I just said/done that seems to be making you more and more agitated and upset?

I read Mentalizing in Clinical Practice after having finished Allen's Restoring Mentalizing in Attachment Relationships: Treating Trauma With Plain Old Therapy. Let me next offer some comments about this book which was also valuable. 

I confess that anyone who uses the phrase "plain old therapy" is going to command my attention rather immediately and easily. I further confess my ever-increasing lack of interest in, and sometimes scorn for, the mad rush of a lot of people to coin and then copyright acronyms and to trademark modalities. Allen has little interest in such things, and I am at one with him here. 

Neither of us, however, is willing to dismiss evidence or defend things merely because we have theoretical preferences. I do not doubt for a moment that in some cases some of these things (DBT, EMDR) work, but it seems clinical psychology is engaged in a frenetic and relentless chase after commodification of its services in a way that is profoundly off-putting, and usually for one of two reasons at least: either much of what is proffered is just needlessly complicated manual therapy like DBT, or recycled earlier approaches. 

In the foreword to this book, Peter Fonagy says that "plain old therapy [is] a mentalizing relationship in which the therapist's empathy allows the patient no longer to feel alone in emotional pain" (xiii). This approach, both he and Allen recognize, antedates all forms of psychotherapy, going back thousands of years and still being practiced today in regular forms of relationship with friends and family who help us by and with their empathy as we struggle. 

This approach, he further recognizes, has much in common with the ever-popular mindfulness today, but he distinguishes them thus:

Mindfulness is attention to and acceptance of present experience

Mentalizing is attention to and acceptance of mental states (mindfulness of mind).

Trauma and the Failures of Attachment:

For Allen, as for Fonagy, a failure of mentalizing often lies behind trauma, attachment failures, and substance abuse. What these situations have in common is that the person is left psychologically alone in distress, and so much find maladaptive ways of coping, including substances, disorganized attachment, or other personality disorders. 

In traumatic failures of attachment, especially situations of childhood abuse and neglect, those attachment failures always get re-enacted in other relationships, showing that re-enacting is always a failure of mentalization (what Freud called "remembering" in his invaluable essay "Remembering, Repeating, and Working Through").

Allen uses an interesting metaphor in working with severely traumatized patients: what were and are their "islands of security"? Find them, explore them, and then see if you can get them off the tiny island and onto a more secure mainland in their own mind. 

Importance of I Statements:

Two final words of counsel I found helpful, and have already seen work well in my consulting room: the first (which other therapists I have read, including Yalom, also recommend) is to give voice to struggles in the session and relationship by using I statements: e.g., "I seem to wonder if we are not going around in circles" and leave it at that. This method often sees the patient pick this up and elaborate, or adopt your view and allow themselves to be carried forward. 

Another effective version of such a statement that I have used with success marries what Allen recommends with what Nina Coltart also recommends: take cool soundings from the counter-transference, paying special attention to images or nick-names that your unconscious throws up. I have found myself saying things like "I have this image of you in mind" or "I'm wondering why I want to give you the nick-name of Invisible Man." Both of these opened up new depths and directions to be explored. 

Minds inside Minds:

Finally Allen notes that the patient has to be able to find him/herself in the therapist's mind just as the therapist has to be in the patient's mind. I think the former might be especially important around those notoriously destabilizing transition moments--a summer holiday or Christmas break, say. For some patients the knowledge that their therapist holds them in mind outside the session can be helpful and healing in itself, especially if they had no significant early attachment figures. 

Diana Fosha on the Transforming Power of Affect

David Arute contacted me on Facebook and initiated a lovely discussion about numerous things. He heads (with his wife) his own psychotherapy clinic outside of Chicago, where they are doing some very interesting work indeed. You can read all about that here. I mention this to give him credit for introducing me to Diana Fosha and her book The Transforming Power of Affect: A Model for Accelerated Change, published by Basic Books more than 20 years ago now. 

I confess that until this conversation I had never even heard of Fosha, but I am grateful to have had that ignorance now challenged, and to have been introduced to her book, which I have read with great interest. My interest grew even stronger upon reading of her background and some of her key theoretical influences. 

Fosha was born in Romania but trained in the US, including time learning with and from Habib Davanloo, whose books I have and have been meaning to read for coming on a year now, without finding the time. Davanloo was a pioneer in a intensive short-term dynamic psychotherapy, an approach that Patricia Coughlin (whose books I also have, but have not had time yet to read) has continued to make known. It is an approach that fascinates me, and once I get around to reading those books, will have plenty to say about it on here! 

As I noted not too long ago, the idea that analytic therapy has to take years is a relatively late development. The very first generation around Freud specialized in short courses of therapy, so the desire to return to those today is not entirely or even primarily born of the usual horrid capitalist demands for brevity and "efficiency." 

I must say this book hooked me with the first lines of an unlikely page: the acknowledgements, where Fosha begins by acknowledging her debts to the great D.W. Winnicott, whose thought I have been drawing on more and more for the past few years, most especially in my essay here on Hating the Church. (In the next breath she acknowledges Davanloo's influence.)

After these, she mentions David Malan, whom I have also marked to read, in my continuing exploration of short therapy; and then, inter alia, Paul Wachtel, whose Therapeutic Communication, Second Edition: Knowing What to Say When I actually have finished reading but not yet posted my thoughts about. 

So, to Fosha then. Having started to read Bowlby, Winnicott, and attachment and object relations theory more than twenty years ago now, I found that her first five chapters were well written if somewhat underwhelming--a refresher for me, but valuable introductory material for those without the theoretical background.  

There were two outstanding insights in this section.

First, I especially appreciated Fosha--after reviewing the literature on defense mechanisms (including Anna Freud's well-known treatment of them)--arguing that defenses should be understood not just as negative barriers (I build a wall to protect myself against anxiety or trauma), but as also leaving a positive residue, which goes some way to explaining their power and hold over us: the wall reduces my sense of anxiety and allows me to feel a bit better, a bit less anxious, perhaps even good about myself. Anything that plays such a pivotal and powerful dual role--protecting me and allowing me to feel if not good then at least less anxious--is very likely going to become deeply rooted in most of us. 

In that sense we must not condemn defenses even if we now see that they are maladaptive and unhelpful. Once more I'm put in mind here of Auden's poem "In Memory of Sigmund Freud," and these verses especially: 

but he would have us remember most of all 
to be enthusiastic over the night,
     not only for the sense of wonder
   it alone has to offer, but also
because it needs our love. With large sad eyes
its delectable creatures look up and beg
     us dumbly to ask them to follow:
   they are exiles who long for the future
that lives in our power, they too would rejoice
if allowed to serve enlightenment like him.

The second insight here is a familiar one to readers of Yalom: Fosha's very strong emphasis on the here-and-now of therapy, on the moment-by-moment affective experience going on in patient and therapist, and between them. This is well captured at the end of chapter six, when she says that "what we discover...is that when dynamically understood, the structure of the sweeping patterns of a lifetime resemble the moment-to-moment dynamic shifts of the current relationship with the therapist" (136). 

Earlier in chapter six, this has become the explicit focus as Fosha argues that the clinician needs to be closely attentive to those micro ruptures and alterations in affect that take place within the session moment by moment. She highlights some of the differences between resilience and resistance in dealing with psychic conflict and anxiety. 

Anxiety, in turn, is linked with affect and attachment, these latter two attempting abatement and regulation of the former. But we must not, Fosha seems to be saying, focus only on anxiety and defenses. There is also a "desire to grow, connect, and feel authentic" (109). The therapeutic task, of course, is to create the environment and conditions where this may happen more fully. 

In chapter seven, Fosha focuses on the patient's love and compassion, and what may have happened to those if they were thwarted, rejected, mocked, or insufficiently received by their intended objects. She notes--as I have seen Harold Searles and others do--that the patient does not just have a need to be healed, but also to able to offer healing to others, including the therapist: "when...empathy is directed toward the therapist, it is extremely important that she acknowledge it" (145), especially in those patients whose empathy more easily and generously extends to others than to themselves. 

A little later on (152-53) this discussion about empathy leads to an interesting analogy: is there such a thing as an unprovoked bear attack? You might think you did everything right to avoid provoking the bear, but it is the bear, not you, who decides whether he is feeling provoked or not! The same is true for the patient, who decides whether he finds you, as therapist, empathic and understanding, warm and accepting, or not. 

Chapter 8's reflections on meta-therapeutic processing includes this useful reminder given to public speakers: tell your audience what you are going to do, do it, and then tell them what you've done. In a similar way, the therapist facilitates the therapeutic environment, names the experience, and then with the patient explores his or her experience of the therapy. This experience of reflecting on one's own experience, Fosha says, is "strongly related to resilience and psychic health" (163), an insight she draws in part from the work of such as Peter Fonagy. Practiced long and well enough, these experiences can lead to a level of emotional mastery whose marks may often persist long after treatment has ended. 

In reflecting on and working through the suffering and losses of one's past, mourning arises and will be greatly aided, Fosha says, by the therapist making manifest and making use of "her own grief and sadness for what the patient has had to endure" (169). Later on she notes that therapy is off to a good start after the "sacred" first session if it is clearly established that "the patient feels safe and the therapist brave" (213) by being willing to become emotionally vulnerable with and for the patient. 

How Are We Doing? 

Much as Yalom suggests, Fosha also later notes that the very first session should not end without the patient "spending some time processing the patient's reaction to being and talking with the therapist" (238). As she elsewhere notes, this should be an entirely open conversation about good and bad: "We try to help the patient verbalize the experience of closeness and distance. Talking about what is happening--good and bad--intensifies the sense of closeness" (220). Here Fosha notes she explicitly departs from a more "traditional" analytic approach that eschews focus on positive transference in favour of the negative. Nothing should be off the table, allowing her to suggest these two questions are central:
  • How do you feel here with me?
  • What is your sense of me? (Or: how do you experience me?)
If the answers to those questions are genuinely positive, then here as elsewhere Fosha says the therapist must not, because of "ill-placed modesty" downplay the discussion of those positive interactions: rather the courage you need, mentioned above, must be brought to bear here for this discussion about positive feelings and interactions is just as therapeutically important, allowing both patient and therapist to ask themselves "could it be that I'm not bad?" (221).

On the Working Alliance:

Next drawing on research into the centrality of the working alliance as crucial to the success of therapy, Fosha notes that therapist's must regularly, consciously, and deliberately engage in "empathic prizing," showing the patient how much their experience is valued and validated (223), both the suffering but also their positive strengths and gifts. The therapist must offer encouragement to keep going, showing a hopeful way forward; and must also offer positive feedback and commendation for whatever progress or successes the patient enjoys, especially calling out and lauding any actions by the patient toward self-care and affirmation. 

Sometimes doing this is a both-and exercise, Fosha suggests: the praise may often be met by a defensive downplaying by the patient, and the therapist's empathy should call both dynamics out, validating the need for the defenses while also encouraging the further taking of risks in precisely this area. 

When it comes to the therapist's feedback and even more his or her self-disclosure, Fosha has an interesting take, noting that especially for those "patients [who] have rarely felt that they have an impact on the significant others of their early life," knowing they are having an impact on the therapist can be transformative (230). This is also true when it comes to acknowledging errors by and limitations of the therapist, and any vulnerabilities. Fosha uses a striking phrase here, noting how the therapist's "self-disclosure [can] counteract therapeutic omnipotence" (231) as well as strengthen the patient's belief that he or she has valuable contributions to make to the welfare of the other. For patients whose relational style is that of learned helplessness, rising to the challenge of helping another can be an important lesson to learn. For patients (and therapists, I might add!) whose relational style tends towards the very intellectual or even quasi-schizoid, asking these sorts of questions, and offering these sorts of reflections, can prove to be "the ultimate corrective emotional experience" (243). 

Working with Defenses:

Noting that explicit challenges to defenses are a hallmark of Davanloo's work and all who come after him in the short-term dynamic psychotherapies, Fosha differentiates between "soft" and "entrenched" defenses, noting that the latter require some form of "restructuring" (247). (In addition to challenging defenses, all these approaches also share another goal and technique: the learning to bear previously unbearable affect in the here-and-now of the working alliance.) Her approach here is refreshingly straightforward: "using empathy," simply begin by talking about the role of defenses with the patient, offering "nonjudgmental feedback to the patient of what it is like to be on the receiving end of his defenses," thereby allowing him or her to become aware of the impact those defenses have on others. 

After this an appreciative reframing of the defenses can take place. But before this, some patients can respond by trying to do too much too fast, overcoming defenses almost by sheer willpower in a given moment, which may lead to frustration. It is important for the therapist to call out this self-pressure and allow it to deflate. 

As work with defenses proceeds, other relational patterns may emerge to be worked on, reflecting patterns in the patient's wider life outside the consulting room. From here the work may proceed to a recasting of the narrative of the patient's life. Specifity and detail are often key here, Fosha says, not least in getting through intellectualization defenses: the more a patient can remember and describe about an experience the more he is likely to be close to what he felt about it, too.