Posts

Showing posts with the label group therapy

Healing Sexually Betrayed Boys and Men

Last year I reviewed a manuscript for Routledge and in exchange for my labours took my remuneration in books, including a copy of this book: Richard B. Gartner, Healing Sexually Betrayed Men and Boys: Treatment for Sexual Abuse, Assault, and Trauma (Routledge, 2018). 

It is the second volume, a companion to Understanding the Sexual Betrayal of Boys and Men: The Trauma of Sexual Abuse (Routledge, 2017).

I have not read the 2017 volume, but on the strength of the second, I will be doing so.

Healing Sexually Betrayed Men and Boys is a very rich collection, only some of which I can hope to convey here. It certainly belongs in the hands of every man or boy who has been victimized, but will be equally valuable to their partners and family members, and of course to clinicians of all traditions. There is a great deal of solid research conveyed here as well as some pioneering programs, and reflections of those pioneering clinicians themselves. 

The book is divided into four sections, with a total of fifteen chapters. Most are written by US clinicians, but several are written by clinicians in Canada, including one, Rick Goodwin, based in Ottawa, where I did my initial training in psychology and underwent psychoanalysis. So his chapter was of special interest to me.

The first section looks at general and global issues in treating men who have been abused. The second looks at focused treatments, including a new program, Weekend of Recovery, and a resource-rich website to which it is connected, MaleSurvivor.org. The third section, "Women in the Picture," looks at female therapists working with male survivors as well as female partners of the same; there is also a section on same-sex partners and their unique challenges. In this section also is a chapter on covert seduction, about which more in a moment. 

The fourth and final section is a rare look at perpetrators who are also survivors/victims, and the very great difficulties that arise when trying to find placements for such men to be treated. I will return to this again later. Each section, and nearly every chapter, also contains often harrowing case material of patients the authors have treated over the years. 

Let me just highlight three chapters while, again, encouraging all those with interest in this area to read the whole book. 

The fourth chapter, co-authored by Howard Fradkin and Jim Struve, "Empowering Male Survivors to Heal through Community and Peer Connections," contains a new model that I have found fascinating. Based on their belief that group work is a crucial adjunct to individual psychotherapy, the authors proposed, plan, and have helped host Weekends of Recovery around the world since 2001. "While not considered therapy, the weekends often have therapeutic benefits," the authors say (102). In this regard, A good bit of the underlying philosophy, they say, comes from that landmark book we all know and love, The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy by Irvin Yalom and Molyn Leszcz; their sixth edition was published just a month ago. There is much here, it seems to me, that would lend itself to Catholic churches borrowing and adapting for similar purposes as parishes and victims try to heal from the never-ending abuse in their midst, which I have addressed at length elsewhere. 

Chapter 11, "Covert Seduction and its Effect on Boys and Men," by Kenneth Adams is deeply interesting, raising a concept I have never heard before: covert seduction, where boys are used emotionally and sexually without actual physical sexual contact in most cases: "you can be sexually abused without being sexually touched" (214). One example of this he focuses on later in the chapter is exposure to pornography, especially at an early age. Other examples include bathing and toilet rituals as well as expecting boys to fulfill emotional and sexual needs of their mothers in the absence, or as rivals to, husbands and fathers. 

The damage this can leave is very real, serious, and long-lasting in many cases, resulting in guilt, schizoid-like detachment, shame, ongoing struggles to detach from the covertly incestuous family member, etc. In therapy, Adams cautions several times, these victims will often be the ideal patients--docile, compliant, reporting positive effects and results. All this is in fact a sign of their pathology: they have learned compliance, docility, and the importance of manifesting positive results as a result of their abuse. 

The last section is useful in highlighting some of the challenges that come from men who were themselves victims before going on to be perpetrators. The authors cite research indicating that this number is much lower than is sometimes portrayed, suggesting it is around 12% of abuse victims who go on to become perpetrators (a number borrowed from Anna Salter's very useful groundbreaking book Predators). Additionally this section contains a helpful typology of abusers, and a section of female abusers as well. 

All told, Richard Gartner and his contributors to Healing Sexually Betrayed Men and Boys: Treatment for Sexual Abuse, Assault, and Trauma have given us many insights (each chapter's lengthy bibliography is very valuable indeed) in this rich and helpful book. I know I shall be returning to it regularly. 

On Learning to Love Group Therapy

When I resumed clinical training last fall after being on a long academic detour for two decades, the biggest area of learning for me has (so far) likely been in the realm of group therapy, first at a theoretical level and now at a clinical and practical level. Very rapidly, and to my amazement, I have gone from strong, if very unthinking, skepticism about groups to an increasing love for work with groups.

I had a class in group therapy in the spring during which the first major revelation came in clarifying that group therapy is not just a collection of individuals who are doing individualized therapy while others watch and benefit vicariously—a kind of therapy as spectacle, as it were. Such an idea of group therapy filled me with a sense of horror that is, moreover, dependent upon my being something of a snob when it comes to education, prizing above all people who’ve obtained MD’s and Ph.D’s. Why should I want to air my problems in a room full of unlettered voyeurs?  

Slowly, however, I came to realize that groups work as such, that is ensemble (as we say in French) rather than as merely a loose aggregate of individuals who happen to find themselves in the room at the same time, each sequentially taking a turn to engage the therapist while the others watch largely in silence. Further, I’m realizing that people can and do learn from others regardless of what degrees or credentials they may possess, and that sometimes these people can be more beneficial, more intelligent, and less blind than the “expert” who has all the degrees in the world. 

The big person to help here has, of course, been Yalom. His landmark book, Group Therapy (the sixth edition of which comes out this December), which I’ve been picking my way through for most of this year, has been so very helpful in many ways. I will be writing more about it in the coming weeks. 

One of his insights I especially appreciated: the fact that groups allow members an opportunity to feel and be helpful. As he puts it, “People need to feel they are needed and useful” (p.14). 

This is a dynamic that Harold Searles, whom I recently stumbled upon, described well in his 1975 paper “The Patient as Therapist to his Analyst.” He argues there, as Yalom does, that all of us have a “psychotherapeutic striving” to be agents of healing to one another. (Indeed, Searles goes even farther to argue that at least part of what we might label “pathology” comes from having this urge to be helpful thwarted.) 

The idea that therapists can and do learn from their patients is another insight I have been regularly encountering in just about every work I have read this year across American and British practice and several theoretical traditions. In this it accords well with something I learned from Stanley Hauwerwas many years ago, and have found a constant part of my experience in the classroom: the extent to which professors learn from their students. In either case what is required is a certain degree of humility and graciousness not to see oneself as an omniscient expert and students or patents as bereft of any insight or wisdom. 

Some of the virtues of groups are highlighted in this article, which points out a forthcoming book by Christie Tate, Group: How One Therapist and a Circle of Strangers Saved My Life. With any luck, I may be able to read it in the coming weeks. I've also written to the author to see if she is open to doing an interview about it. Here, in the meantime, is the publisher's blurb:

The refreshingly original debut memoir of a guarded, over-achieving, self-lacerating young lawyer who reluctantly agrees to get psychologically and emotionally naked in a room of six complete strangers—her psychotherapy group—and in turn finds human connection, and herself.

Christie Tate had just been named the top student in her law school class and finally had her eating disorder under control. Why then was she driving through Chicago fantasizing about her own death? Why was she envisioning putting an end to the isolation and sadness that still plagued her in spite of her achievements?

Enter Dr. Rosen, a therapist who calmly assures her that if she joins one of his psychotherapy groups, he can transform her life. All she has to do is show up and be honest. About everything—her eating habits, childhood, sexual history, etc. Christie is skeptical, insisting that that she is defective, beyond cure. But Dr. Rosen issues a nine-word prescription that will change everything: “You don’t need a cure, you need a witness.”

So begins her entry into the strange, terrifying, and ultimately life-changing world of group therapy. Christie is initially put off by Dr. Rosen’s outlandish directives, but as her defenses break down and she comes to trust Dr. Rosen and to depend on the sessions and the prescribed nightly phone calls with various group members, she begins to understand what it means to connect.

Group is a deliciously addictive read, and with Christie as our guide—skeptical of her own capacity for connection and intimacy, but hopeful in spite of herself—we are given a front row seat to the daring, exhilarating, painful, and hilarious journey that is group therapy—an under-explored process that breaks you down, and then reassembles you so that all the pieces finally fit.

The Gift of Yalom (I)

My clinical supervisor very off-handedly mentioned "Yalom" in class one day last year and everyone seemed to know what/who that was. I had no clue. I half-figured it was one of those myriad acronyms for some gimmicky "technique" modern psychology loves, if only for purposes of trade-marking and marketing and thus money-making.  

I have been happily rectifying my ignorance since then by reading several of Irvin Yalom's books, starting with his landmark work, which I used for a project in a group therapy class: The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy, which is fascinating and so much better written than any textbook I've read so far in the area. I expect this will be the kind of book I shall return to often in the coming years. 

Next up I ordered The Gift of Therapy. It, too, will reward re-reading over the years. It is, in some respects, almost a collection of aphorisms, though most chapters are a little longer than the typical aphorism, and in that regard the subtitle is apt: An Open Letter to a New Generation of Therapists and Their Patients. 

The book's 85 chapters are thus seen as something longer than an aphorism but shorter than a really long letter: they are in fact short letters, some of them less than a page, and the longest of them just over six pages. Yalom writes with a light and often charming touch, so these are an easy read. 

That is not to say they are flippant in any way. Some of these letters strike me as such obvious counsel that they do not need saying (e.g., ch. 64, "Never be Sexual with Patients"), but clearly they do need saying as sexual abuse by clinicians is by no means unknown even today. One of the startling and disgusting experiences of my undergraduate days was finding out that a professor, whom I really liked, who had taught a class on personality theories, which was one of my favourite classes, was later tried by the College of Psychologists of Ontario and had his license stripped after on-going sexual relationships with several patients, to whom he was later ordered by the courts to pay extensive damages. 

Part of the motivation for writing this book, Yalom says in the introduction, is that "our field is in such crisis," in large part because (at least in America under its horrid and rapacious health insurance industry) of the pressure that all therapy be "brief, superficial, and insubstantial." Such pressures (ongoing in 2020, as this letter from Division 39 of the APA shows) mean that mental healthcare today is running the risk of being "deformed by economic pressures and impoverished by radically abbreviated training programs" (xv). It is for those who also want to resist these pressures, and learn how to offer a form of therapy that is deeper, longer, and open to exploring existential issues (about which Yalom has written elsewhere several times) that Yalom has written The Gift of Therapy. 

Part of what immediately endeared Yalom to me is that he makes it plain that his enemies are also mine: he is explicitly "against sectarianism" and in favour of "therapeutic pluralism in which effective interventions are drawn from several different therapy approaches" (xv). Some of his friends are also mine, and so I happily note his positive references to such existentialists as Paul Tillich and others, including Nietzsche. 

Even more delightful was to encounter a name I have not seen, nor read, since high-school: Rainer Maria Rilke, whose Letters to a Young Poet I read at a crucial time and have stayed with me all these years later as an example of what Christopher Bollas (in his first and, to my mind, still his best book, The Shadow of the Object) would recognize as a largely unconscious "transformational object." Rilke shows up again at the end of ch.3, where Yalom quotes his wise counsel: "Have patience with everything unresolved and try to love the questions themselves" to which Yalom himself adds "try to love the questioners as well."

Yalom's The Gift of Therapy exhibits an openness to the questions and insights from giants of the near-past without idolizing them: names like Karen Horney (who graces the first page of ch.1), Winnicott, Ferenczi, Fromm, Erikson, and of course Freud are cited here with critical appreciation. Given its nature ("this volume is in no way meant to be a systematic manual") it does not of course lend itself to a standard review, so instead I shall simply mosey around the book highlighting things that stand out. (This will be an on-going series of posts.)

Chapter 3 opens with an observation Yalom draws from the French novelist André Malraux about one of his characters: "there is no such thing as a grown-up person." That immediately put me in mind of Adam Phillips, the other person I have spent the last four years reading very closely, and who will feature on this blog regularly. He says in one of his many books that "we remain children for a very long time." In this light I am also minded to think of an observation I heard (perhaps in the Ken Burns' PBS series The Roosevelts?) someone make about Teddy Roosevelt to the effect that "you have to understand the president is, at heart, just a six-year-old boy." It's a pity too many of us would regard that as a fault or failing!

In ch.4 and elsewhere, Yalom offers a simple question I have started using with people and that is to ask them some version of this: As you are driving home today/leaving from here, what are you telling yourself about this conversation? What are you taking away? This, as he says later, is a useful window to help him see that he and the patient do not always "have the same experience during the hour." 

Ch. 5 offers one pithy bit of advice: "Don't be stingy" in offering positive feedback to patients. Too many today, Yalom fears, may in fact be stingy, and I would wonder if some of this does not go back to Freud's rule of "abstinence" in that the therapist was to leave the patient as undisturbed as possible by refusing to offer advice or feedback. But as Paul Roazen has demonstrated, Freud talking to fellow therapists comes across as strict and forbidding, but Freud's own clinical practice was often much more relaxed about the rules he laid down (and sometimes, as the correspondence with Ferenczi makes clear, this was not always to the good!). 

Ch. 7 deftly deals with statements from patients such as "you must be bored of me by now" by turning them around: "Is there a question in there for me? "

Ch.8 (without quoting her) sounds very similar to advice the great Nina Coltart (about whom I have a post coming) offers in allowing patients to matter to therapists, and not to be afraid to acknowledge that. This must be nicely judged, however, so that things do not get too awry and patients matter too much or the counter-transference gets out of hand. But to be totally unmoved, sitting in lofty and aloof silence, will help nobody.


Several times throughout the book Yalom says that therapists should just acknowledge a cock-up and deal with it openly: "I'm sorry I made a mistake" will help things get back on track more swiftly and successfully than pretending nothing happened.

Several times he also uses words like "spontaneous," "dynamic," and "ever-evolving" to describe how therapy should proceed, and in this way pushes back against the increasing tendency towards manualized, standardized "therapy."

Yalom's Ch.12, with which I shall end for now, contains what I regard as the central and most important insight and counsel in the entire book, captured by its title: "Engage in personal therapy." I am frankly amazed that plenty of people can enter the therapeutic vocation (as Coltart rightly calls it) without having undergone, and regularly undergoing, their own therapy. As I have argued elsewhere recently, a personal psychoanalysis has been the most transformational experience of my life and I remain profoundly grateful.