Posts

Showing posts with the label Carlos Dominguez-Morano

Desire: An Enigma Wrapped In Riddles Inside Mystery

Introduction:

I learn such things on Twitter. 

I forget to whom exactly to give credit for introducing me to Galit Atlas and her book, The Enigma of Desire: Sex, Longing, and Belonging in Psychoanalysis (Routledge, 2016). It may well have first been Adam Rodriguez, but I know it was even more forcefully Taylor Zimmerman, whom I met with great delight in Indianapolis in April at the celebrated day with Jonathan Shedler. Over the coffee hour and in subsequent correspondence, Taylor strongly encouraged me to read Atlas, so I am grateful to him as to Adam. 

Atlas is the third person in an ongoing series of clinicians in whom I am finding much wisdom with regard to erotic dynamics in psychotherapy, especially in the transference and countertransference. The first of these was, and is, Andrea Celenza, about whom I first wrote here, and more recently here. 

She and Glen Gabbard are arguably the two leading scholar-clinicians writing on sexualized boundary violations in professional contexts, including clinical and clerical contexts. Given the power of their writings, and the fact these topics are almost universally ignored in all training programs, and even by licensed professionals, I am at the point now where I just flatly tell anyone who asks, and even more who don't, that they should buy all of Gabbard's books and all of Celenza's and read them. Were I in charge of training programs in this country for future clinicians of all sorts, I would absolutely make these two authors mandatory reading. 

Into this group I now can bring Galit Atlas, who writes in a different style and with a different focus than Gabbard and Celenza, but with them is still broadly in the field--hitherto often terribly overlooked or denied--of erotic dynamics in treatment. Her book, The Enigma of Desire, puts me in mind of another recent treatment by another psychoanalyst, Carlos Dominguez-Morano (whose utterly irreplaceable Belief After Freud should also be required reading, not least by Christians still talking bollocks about Freud), The Myth of Desire: Sexuality, Love, and the Self, which I have to go back and re-read. 

Right, down to business. 

Atlas on Maternal Erotics:

Atlas begins punchily enough in her introduction by arguing that "In treatment, adopting the role of a nurturing mother can function as the therapist's way to avoid the erotic material that emerges between her and the patient." This I take to be just another version of the important warning (echoed by Shedler, Maroda, McWilliams, and many others) that being too much of a "container" (Bion) or providing little more than a "holding environment" (Winnicott) will mean you ultimately fail your patient who is there because something is wrong and something needs to be changed, not merely contained. 

A second related warning follows from this later in the book (p.80): "our patients' traumatized self-states may collude with our own in order to protect the tender parts of the self, the other, and the treatment from damage by the aggressive parts." (This, of course, is reason #23689 for the psychotherapist to have had his or her own in-depth and intensive long-term psychotherapy, and to engage in regular supervision and consultation.)

Also early in her book Atlas makes plain her own debts to what she calls Kleinian mothers, who have led her to be able "to trust the mind to lead us to the most unknown truths and to believe that the ability to tolerate those tensions allows us to live and to love." She also mentions her debts to Laplanche and Kristeva, and Jessica Benjamin, especially this: "I do not believe we can definitely know what belongs to us and what belongs to our patients." 

This point, of course, puts one in mind of Thomas Ogden's celebrated notion of the analytic third, and of the inability, as he has also recognized, to know where the patient's experience ends and the clinician's begins. 

The Erotics of Writing:

There is a sensuous quality to Atlas's writing itself, not least in her case studies, which are presented here in ways that are less stilted and bloodless than one so often finds. That is to say, there is still a warm pulse in the people she writes about. 

Moreover, and more interesting for me who has long loved to write and cared deeply about the felicities and rewards of style, and who has often felt a flush of excitement in the exchange of ideas, she openly acknowledges that "While writing, I found myself...swinging from feeling overaroused and exposed to using ideas as a way to distance, process, and regulate" (p.30). Lest we miss the point, a bit later she quotes a famous 1989 paper of Ronald Britton in which he recounts a patient demanding: "'Stop that fucking thinking'!" From this Atlas deduces that "thinking is a form of the therapist's internal intercourse" (p.32). Just so! 

I can relate to that outside the consulting room, but also in, which she captures with equal candor: "I notice the movement between moments of sexual stimulation and arousal to use of theory....I believe we often experience the same movement as analysts trying to regulate ourselves and our patients when the erotic pervades the analytic space" (p.30). Guilty as charged! (If I find myself becoming very theoretical, or subjecting the patient to a lecture, than I know my intellectualized defenses have led to such an enactment, and, following Fonagy's counsel, I need to rewind the session back to the point where I was able to mentalize before the defenses were, uh, aroused.)

The Enigmatic and the Pragmatic:

The unique contribution that Atlas make, so far as I can see at this point, is her stress on what she calls Enigmatic and Pragmatic knowing. Much more could be said about this, but I don't want to give all of the book away, so suffice it for me to say that the enigmatic and pragmatic are tied to her dual understanding of the origins of, changes in, and different desires manifested in sexuality: "the erotic comes into existence when the sexuality that at the start was based exclusively on nourishment and satisfaction of hunger moves away from the functional and toward play" (p.41). 

Do not, she warns later, be too enchanted (as some of us who love Winnicott are inclined to be) by notions of play, for these, too, can be used to displace certain important things: "playfullness can be a seductive way to express erotic and aggressive contents...but it's important to note that it can also serve to obstruct erotic transference and countertransference" (p.81). Yes it can, as I've noticed in some sessions after the fact, and not without some chagrin! 

Sexual Longing and Erotic Manifestations and Their Dangers:

Her mention of the erotic obstructing transference material takes us back onto more familiar ground, also covered by Gabbard and Celenza, and then by David Mann, whose two books on the topic I began last weekend, and about which I will have a very great deal to say later (O lucky reader!). 

Rightly does Atlas note early in the book that "sometimes we underestimate how dangerous it feels to be part of a dyad." I try to remind myself of that at least a few times a week, and (for some reason) it always happens at the last turn of the corridor immediately before bringing a patient into my consulting room. In those seconds as I usher them in, I cast my mind back to the first time I ever met with a psychotherapist (a pastoral counselor as I recall) in my teen years (to discuss sexual matters, too!), and how anxious I felt: I try to get a feel for whether this person with me is also a bit anxious, which is an entirely understandable feeling for, as Atlas continues a bit later, "being a patient is a dangerous position" for the patient may feel "he is forced back into the powerless position of being a child to a seductive mother who penetrates and excites him, feeds him but also controls his food and will certainly abandon him, leaving him overexcited, humiliated, and alone" (p.37). 

Strong stuff! No wonder people on Twitter lose their bloody minds when you speak such thoughts aloud; no wonder my undergrads had a collective meltdown at the mention of any hint of anything remotely "erotic" in the therapeutic relationship; no wonder even licensed professionals shy away from these discussions at best, and at worst become amusingly and revealingly hyper-defended. 

Why would anyone submit to this humiliating penetration and abandonment? Later she notes some of its rewards: "Allowing yourself to be penetrated means embracing a more fluid structure that is based on unsolidified boundaries....This is not exclusively a feminine process" (p.69). Indeed not. 

Precisely my attraction to psychoanalytic thinking, starting with Freud, more than three decades ago now was because it seemed to be quite at home with the idea of the fluidity, the complexity, the ambiguity and ambivalence--the sheer messiness--of human sexuality. I have always been highly suspicious of anyone who wants to put it into neat boxes, or map it out on a linear continuum or Kinsey scale. None of us is ever "straight." 

Before going further, she reminds us that for many of us, we had (referring to Kohut) no "mirroring" of the erotic and sexual growing up: "sexual feelings are unique in that caregivers systematically ignore them and they are therefore unmirrored" (p.115). This will and will not show up in a variety of ways in life, and in therapy. 

For some this lack of mirroring can leave the terror of such feelings in place, and that is where you must begin in therapy: "are there ways to listen for, and to, the unique accents of the language of sex." And if those accents are ones of fear, then, nodding towards Bion, Atlas says that an early task of the second mind in the room is to help the first mind bear to think about those fearful desires and terrifying thoughts.

As you think about them, some of the difficulty of such feelings comes from the fact that "sexual longing presupposes a sense of loss and a hope of refinding." 

That refinding is not a straightforward path from infantile attachment to adult sexual longings. It is often much more complicated than that, and thus the clinician needs to proceed with due caution: "the secret psychoanalytic touch is always about tolerating the erotic in the room while not adding to the stimulus." 

Earlier, she notes that we can and probably should do more than that: "we try to hold the unknown darkness with them, tolerate the 'too muchness' of excitement, joy, horror, and shame." Later she will speak of the "suffering of pleasure, of the excess that the body and the mind cannot contain," to which some might give the name "lust" while others (here Melanie Klein) prefer to speak of "human yearning for an 'unattainable perfect internal state'." 

Enactments Made and Redeemed:

Atlas is making what seems to me a very significant advance on how we think about therapeutic enactments. That word is almost universally taken as a sign of danger and enactments seem almost always to be treated sternly. This mirrors, it seems to me, the early Freud and his unidimensional warnings about the dangers of transference and countertransference especially. Only after 1950 did we start to get some limited reflection on what positive things countertransference might contain, and only much later--that is, within the relational movement of which Atlas is a significant part--do we start to see people recognize that countertransference can often be a positive good and contain much valuable information.

Similarly, Atlas is, in the last section of the last chapter of her book, opening up new territory by arguing that enactments are not just "a return of past dissociated memories but rather as the threshold for the introduction of emergent ways of being, of an opening toward new relational possibilities" (p.150). Enactments thus "work toward the future."

They do more than that, as becomes clear in her attempted definition: "enactments may well be a central means by which patients and analysts enter into each other's inner world and discover themselves as participants within each other's psychic life" (p.150). This does not guarantee, of course, that all enactments will always have a positive outcome, but it does begin to help them lose some of their fear, just as we have overcome fear from a century ago of countertransference as a sign of an insufficiently analyzed analyst. 

A concluding word that reminds us of how demanding our vocation as psychotherapists is, for we "must straddle a paradox, always skeptical, questioning, seeking hidden meanings, searching for unconscious dynamics at play, the trailing edge, a hermeneutics of suspicion--while also, paradoxically, trusting unconscious process and surrendering to the continuous flow of the enactive dimension of analysis, relying on a hermeneutics of faith" (here referencing Ricoeur).

Psychoanalysis and Christianity

Prologue:

A tedious bit of autobiography: since 1990, when I was in gr. 12 first reading Freud and Jung and trying to decide, first, what I was to study at university the following year (psychology? theology? history?) and, second, whether to pursue clinical and then analytic training in Montréal, or priestly ordination into the Anglican Church of Canada, I have lived my life at the intersection of theology and psychoanalysis. When I went on sabbatical in 2018, my project was to finally write the book I had been carrying around in my head for nearly thirty years at that point, then tentatively titled "Theology After Freud." (Events intervened and I turned my sabbatical project to writing Everything Hidden Shall Be Revealed: Ridding the Church of Abuses of Sex and Power, where Freud features very prominently and unapologetically throughout). 

I may yet write that book, though increasingly with a much different focus. Some of its materials have in the last decade worked their way into lectures on the relationship between theology (especially Orthodox and Catholic theology) and psychoanalysis that I have gladly given before academic and ecclesial audiences in England and Wales, Canada, and in several places across these United States. A version of that lecture is available here as a podcast.

The other development in 2018 that swayed me against writing my book on psychoanalysis was the appearance of the most powerful theological engagement of Freud I have ever read. The Spanish psychotherapist and Jesuit Carlos Dominguez-Morano (who has published many books in his native tongue, few, alas, having been translated into English) published Belief After Freud: Religious Faith Through the Crucible of Psychoanalysis. That book is, and remains, a stunning work of far-reaching criticism of the most prominent manifestations of the massive psychopathology at the heart of Catholic Christianity. I could only salute the author's penetrating insights and great courage in writing a much more forceful book than I would have attempted. If you read nothing else on this list, read, mark, and inwardly digest this book. The Catholic Church would be a far less objectively disordered and sadomasochistic institution if Dominguez-Morano's proposals were taken at all seriously, which they won't be. (I wrote a bit about him for the Jesuit periodical America, and in more detail at an old blog.) 

If you read Morano and then want to read more in this area, I have, over the last three decades, read as many books about religion and psychoanalysis as I can lay my hands on--with many more to read! What follows are a few notes on disastrous books to avoid, a few that are "good enough," and a rare few that our outstanding. 

Books Fit for Burning:

Previously I noted on here one book that, had it been edited and published properly, would have been a handy collection to have. But it was so shoddily produced it's not fit for reading and the publisher should be ashamed to have foisted such slop on us. 

The other book is one I can only think of as psychotic: by that I mean Bion's theory of psychosis as the severance of all meaning-making links and possibilities for rationality and reality-testing. I cannot in all honesty discern any sort of rational purpose to the book as it staggers around vomiting out incoherent statements unconnected to any sort of discernible purpose--or to each other. The Freud who features here, and the "arguments" made, bear no relationship to reality. There is of course no end of attacks on Freud, and almost all of them are at least generally coherent (see, e.g., Frederick Crews), but this book could not even manage to rise to the level of childish diatribe. 

Mediocre Treatments:

Beyond such egregious examples, there are plenty of books in which others might quite rightly find value but I found to be very thin gruel indeed. Most of them were written in too general a way, and often very poorly edited. Under this heading I include Christianity & Psychoanalysis: A New Conversation, eds. Earl D. Bland and Brad D. Strawn; and Marie Hoffman's sprawling Toward Mutual Recognition: Relational Psychoanalysis and the Christian Narrative. Her premise and methods were good but the execution very poor. Other books along these lines could be mentioned but need not detain us further. 

Good General Treatments:

If you are new to the area, then a 30,000-foot overview provided by one of the great scholar-clinicians and social critics of the last century, Erich Fromm, is a good place to start: Psychoanalysis and Religion was originally delivered as part of the Terry Lectures at Yale. Like all Fromm's books, it is written at a very general and accessible level. (I discuss Fromm in a bit more detail here but keep meaning to get back to him at some point.) 

A more advanced but still general treatment may be found in William Meissner, the Jesuit psychiatrist and psychoanalyst I wrote about in my America piece, who authored several decent books, including Psychoanalysis and Religious Experience.

Two other collections merit mention: Soul on the Couch: Spirituality, Religion, and Morality in Contemporary Psychoanalysis, eds. Charles Spezzano and Gerald Gargiulo is decent. Even better is Psychoanalysis and Religion in the 21st Century: Competitors or Collaborators? ed. David M. Black.

Ana-Maria Rizzuto's Works:

The Argentine-born but American-educated Catholic psychiatrist and psychoanalyst remains too little known, in my view, but deserves to be for her first book in 1979, The Birth of the Living God, which was based on fascinating and highly original research with psychiatric inpatients and their internalized God objects. 

Then her 1998 book Why Did Freud Reject God?, published by Yale, is the most careful and respectful such treatment yet published of a topic that almost always sees authors descend to the level of puerile polemics and "pseudo-mentalizing" (to borrow a phrase from Fonagy). 

Only recently has Rizzuto come in for some attention in this decent collection: Ana-María Rizzuto and the Psychoanalysis of Religion: The Road to the Living God, eds. Martha J. Reineke and David M. Goodman.

Winnicott and Religion:

Back when I taught undergraduates theology, I came across the works of the scholar and Jungian clinician Ann Ulanov, author of such books as Finding Space: Winnicott, God, and Psychic Reality as well as Primary Speech: A Psychology of Prayer (which my students loved). 

Stephen Parker has written an unexpectedly excellent monograph (I say "unexpectedly" because works like this are often ploddingly dull, having all the vices of a doctoral dissertation and none of its virtues), Winnicott and Religion, which is very much worth your time if you love Winnicott half as much as I do. Winnicott, as always, has a lovely and useful phrase to describe his own relationship to the Methodism and Anglicanism in which he was reared: traditions to "grow up out of." That phrase admits of wider application today if much research (e.g., Stephen Bullivant's important new book Nonverts: The Making of Ex-Christian America is to be believed on declining practices. 

Highly Specialized Scholarly Monographs:

Under this heading I put two dense but worthwhile works: Peter Tyler's The Pursuit of the Soul: Psychoanalysis, Soul-making and the Christian Tradition; and then Marcus Pound's Theology, Psychoanalysis and Trauma. Pound's book has the virtue of making some of Lacan accessible--a figure whom I otherwise find needlessly and vexatiously obscure so much of the time (though I did find something useful in him as I argued here). 

One of the best books I have read is Pia Sophia Chaudhari's Dynamis of Healing: Patristic Theology and the Psyche. I discussed its virtues and interviewed her about it here. 

Let me end with a new book I forgot to mention in a recent post on On Bare Attention: it is a book by Paul Marcus entitled Psychoanalysis as a Spiritual Discipline: In Dialogue with Martin Buber and Gabriel Marcel. The book is a bit choppy in execution, but it draws out useful material from its two named interlocutors. I read some of Marcel and Bueber in writing my M.A. in moral philosophy at the end of the 1990s (when I read rather a lot more of Alasdair MacIntyre and Emmanuel Levinas, whose "ethics of the face" and critique of abstraction I still teach to my students). 

Marcus seems to suggest in this book that for people who both find themselves "ecclesially homeless" (to use a phrase of Stanley Hauerwas) or "deconstructing" their faith, or otherwise alienated from religious institutions, and are clinicians or interested in psychoanalysis, then the analytic tradition offers both insights and "disciplines" similar to ascetical practices found in Judaism, Christianity, and Buddhism. This allows him to say that "psychoanalysis can reasonably be conceptualized as a spiritual/moral venture." As such, it has practices of "communion" (to borrow a term from Marcel) or what Marcus calls "the five essential elements of psychotherapeutic support--presence, holding, caring, challenging, and confirming."

 

The Deceptions of Desire

Regular readers of my other blog, and especially my book Everything Hidden Shall Be Revealed: Ridding the Church of Abuses of Sex and Power, will be aware of how indebted I am to the Spanish Jesuit psychoanalyst Carlos Dominguez-Morano and his landmark and brilliant book Belief After Freud. That book remains, far and away, the most theologically sophisticated, compelling, and important engagement of Freud for decades. 

Well, to my enormous excitement, I see that Lexington Books is bringing out another of his books in translation next month: The Myth of Desire: Sexuality, Love, and the Self, trans. Veronica Polo Torok (Lexington, November 2020), 254pp.

About this book the publisher tells us this:

In The Myth of Desire: Sexuality, Love, and the Self, Carlos Domínguez-Morano draws on psychoanalysis to explore the broad and complex reality of the affective-sexual realm encompassed by the term desire, a concept that propels individual aspirations, pursuits, and life endeavors. Domínguez-Morano takes a global perspective in order to introduce a methodology, examine the present sociocultural determinations affecting desire, review the main stages in the evolution of desire, and reflect on affective maturity. Domínguez-Morano further explores the five basic expressions of desire: falling in love and being a couple, homosexuality, narcissism and self-esteem, friendship, and the derivative of desire by way of sublimation. Scholars of psychology, philosophy, and sociology will find this book particularly useful.

You can be sure I will have rather a lot to say once I get my hands on this book!  

Happy Birthday!

Welcome to this blog, which will offer regular notes on, comments about, and reviews of books, old and new, in psychotherapy, psychoanalysis, pastoral counselling, and clinical mental health counselling. I will also draw your attention to new and forthcoming books, some of which I may eventually get around to reviewing but others of which are simply posted for your own information.


Taken by me in June 2016 in Vienna at
Bergasse 19.
I have blogged elsewhere for nearly a decade, concentrating in other academic areas in which I have expertise. 

Beyond blogging, I have written extensively for popular and professional periodicals, and peer-reviewed journals in Europe, Australia, Canada, and the United States. I have two books in print, and two more that should be in print by the end of this calendar year or early 2021. In addition, I am working on a book tentatively titled Theology After Freud. 

After a process of careful consideration, including a fellowship at the Chicago Psychoanalytic Institute in 2018-2019, I decided in 2019 to resume clinical training that I set aside (temporarily, I thought) in the late 1990s when, quite unexpectedly, I was offered a teaching position at a Catholic high-school in Ottawa. Up until that point my plan had been to pursue graduate training in pastoral counselling or classical psychoanalysis, but teaching quickly became, and remains, a great love, and I have now done it in three different countries with both high-school and university students for more than two decades.

During all that time, my scholarly research has continued to draw on contemporary clinical and theoretical insights, especially from a psychoanalytic perspective. My most recent book, Everything Hidden Shall Be Revealed: Ridding the Church of Abuses of Sex and Power, draws on Freud and more contemporary psychoanalysts in trying to understand some of the problems within the Catholic Church.

The books to be noted on here will reflect some of my reading and research during the course of my clinical training, but will also discuss many other books besides that, for I read constantly and far more widely than what is assigned in a given course. I will also import reviews I have written elsewhere for several years now, especially of books in psychoanalysis, of which I remain an unapologetic proponent for its therapeutic value in my own life as well as its intellectually compelling explanatory power in many (but certainly not all) areas. 

At the same time, however, I am not an ideologue, and fully recognize--thanks to the works of such as Paul Roazen, Peter Rudnytsky, and Adam Phillips, inter alia, as well, more recently, Jonathan Shedler--the dangers of turning psychoanalysis, or any other therapeutic tradition into an all-encompassing explanation of the human condition or a technique for treating human suffering to the exclusion of all other traditions and perspectives. The conformism of too many psychoanalytic institutes has been destructive and pernicious, but so too has been the blind faith some have put more recently in psychotropics as well as so-called evidence-based treatments like CBT, whose bloated eminence I regard with a wary eye precisely insofar as its apologists seem unconsciously bent on replicating exactly the same political dynamics that turned psychoanalysis into a closed system and an ideology in many places, unwilling and unable to bear legitimate criticism. 

But psychoanalysis, as I have learned from Adam Phillips, Todd McGowan, and Todd Dufresne, at least contains the seeds of undoing its own tendency toward closed ideological thinking. It retains, as the philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre would say, the capacity both for putting itself into an epistemological crisis, and for conceiving of ways by which to emerge from such a crisis.

My formation in and debts to the psychoanalytic tradition broadly and diversely conceived (especially the British Independent/Middle school of people like Nina Coltart, W.R.D. Fairbairn, Harry Guntrip, and D.W. Winnicott) do not prevent me from realizing the huge insights that have been gained since Freud's death just over eighty years ago. I continue to learn from as many traditions as possible--inside and outside the psychoanalytic family--and I am not at all opposed to newer traditions and techniques like, e.g., EMDR, which I have been reading about with great interest for a couple of months now, and about which will write more later.  

One thing I have learned from psychoanalysis is a wariness of system-building and of overly systematic or overly tidy approaches to most things. It has also engendered in me a deep skepticism for romanticism and idealism, and any form of rigid ideological thinking, especially in historiography and humanities scholarship more generally. All this is perhaps best captured in what I regard as a stunning recent book by a Spanish psychoanalyst and Jesuit, Carlos Dominguez-Morano (about whom much more another time). In his Belief After Freud, he writes that the benefits of both theology and psychoanalysis are the same: they disabuse one of the “haughty pretension of having reached ‘the answer.’ Many taxing questions will remain open forever. We are, thus, invited to the healthy asceticism of renouncing total synthesis. The faith that confronts psychoanalysis learns to live and remain in the modesty of tentative formulations” 

This blog will offer a lot of tentative formulations. So do not expect it to be concerned with constructing grand theories or building or defending empires based on any one tradition or technique. It will range freely and widely across traditions and times, looking at what is new and what is old in books published about psychotherapy, psychoanalysis, and counselling, guided primarily by this question: what here is good and will contribute to the healing and flourishing of the human person? 

Thus, this blog will not be anything other than a "loose baggy monster," an eclectic collection of books, an omnium gatherum if you will. Notes and reviews will be posted simply according to what I happen to be reading at any given moment--which is usually not less than six books at least--or what happens to attract my eye in, e.g., new catalogues of forthcoming books from various publishers. 

In the meantime, let us begin this blog's birthday  by going back to say happy birthday to the great man who was born on this day in 1856. It was Freud who taught us--in Auden's words--to "approach the Future as a friend/without a wardrobe of excuses." I look forward to continuing to do that in here in the months ahead. Welcome!